Land is becoming the scarcest input in African farming, and three pieces published within a fortnight show why from three angles. A Potsdam Institute study in Nature Sustainability finds that the world cannot hold warming near 1.5°C without the land sector, yet that land based climate action could squeeze food production, especially in poorer countries. The FAO has released a guide to producing more with fewer resources. And a South African fruit exporter describes how integrating its own farms with partner growers builds resilience. This article asks a practical question for African cooperatives, agribusinesses and governments: if land cannot simply expand, how do yields, quality and incomes rise on the land farmers already have?
Read this first. We read the two Down To Earth reports, on the PIK study and on the FAO guide, and the FreshPlaza article on Star South Group in full. We did not read the Nature Sustainability paper or the FAO guide themselves, so their figures are as reported. The Star South statements are the company’s own. Evidence on seeds, mechanisation, extension and land deals comes from published African studies, most of them before 2026. Research stops at 13 November 2026.
Six findings
- Land based climate action competes with food. Using bioenergy alone would need 267 million hectares by 2050, against 66 million when combined with forest protection and farm emission cuts.
- The poorest may carry the load. If carbon prices are uniform, much of the land based mitigation would fall in developing countries, where more people depend on farming.
- Africa’s seeds, machines and advice lag. Informal seed supplies roughly 70% to 90% of seed, tractors number under 2 per 1,000 hectares, and extension coverage varies from 43 agents per 10,000 farmers in Ethiopia to 2 in India.
- Evidence for each lever is mixed. Mobile advice raised yields about 4% in a meta analysis; state tractor schemes mostly collapsed.
- Past land rushes disappointed. Only 11% of contracted land in one tally was confirmed in production.
- Integration is one answer, not the only one. Star South combines own farms, partner growers and imports to smooth supply.
The squeeze from climate policy
The PIK team modelled how land based measures can contribute to climate targets: protecting forests and other ecosystems, cutting methane and nitrous oxide from livestock, rice and fertiliser, and expanding bioenergy. For a pathway holding peak warming to 1.7°C, they estimate biomass cultivation could be limited to 66 million hectares by 2050 if bioenergy is combined with ecosystem protection, restoration and farm emission cuts, against 267 million if bioenergy does the whole job. Leaving land out entirely would raise the modelled loss in consumption from 1.3% to 3.5% and would make 1.5°C unattainable this century. The study cautions that its results depend on future crop yield gains, and that it does not capture every way higher energy costs could feed into food prices.
Million hectares of biomass cultivation by 2050 in a pathway peaking at 1.7°C. PIK study in Nature Sustainability, 11 November 2026, as reported by Down To Earth
Modelled loss in consumption relative to current policies, per cent, for the same pathway. PIK study as reported
The geography matters for Africa. The study notes that under uniform emission prices a large share of land based mitigation would occur in developing countries, where food prices could rise and where more people depend on agriculture. One of its authors says the potential for land based climate protection lies largely in the Global South, where food shortages, water scarcity and biodiversity loss are already pressing. Irrigated bioenergy plantations could also add water stress. For African ministries negotiating climate finance, the study is a reminder that farm emission cuts and yield gains are also land saving tools.
What Africa’s own land rush taught
The continent has seen land based energy hopes before. Between 2005 and 2013 biofuel investments, especially jatropha, flooded into Mozambique, Tanzania and elsewhere. A GIGA analysis of the Land Matrix found 23% of concluded transnational land deals involved agrofuel crops, sub Saharan Africa was the favoured region and jatropha projects failed often. A UK funded policy brief concluded that large scale jatropha was not viable without irrigation and other inputs, and that some projects restricted communities’ access to water and land; one Tanzanian project took 8,211 hectares from 11 villages. A tally reported by Timothy Wise found that of 37 million hectares under contract across all land deals, only 4.1 million were confirmed in production. These figures are from 2014 to 2016, so they show history, not today’s market.
Share of contracted land confirmed in production in the Land Matrix tally reported by Timothy Wise (2016). Global data; the 89% remainder is our arithmetic
The FAO’s answer: more and better with fewer resources
The FAO guide, Optimization and Minimization: Towards Sustainable Plant Production, names five linked areas: seed systems, crop production systems, integrated pest management, mechanisation, and extension and advisory services. It notes that crop production provides over 80% of the world’s calories and could account for about 80% of added food needs by 2050, and that pests destroy up to 40% of global production each year. We test each area against African evidence below.
Seeds: PARI brief, M&G and Sperling. Pests: FAO. Machines: FAO via PARI. Advice: Davis et al. and IFPRI. “Practices” points to evidence in this article’s earlier sections
Seeds: the first lever and the least formal
A PARI brief says 70% to 80% of seed used in Africa is farm saved, with maize the exception. Other estimates put informal systems at more than 80% or up to 85% of seed planted, and a widely cited dataset found farmers sourced 90.2% of seed informally, including 50.9% from local markets and 98% for grain legumes. The range reflects crops and countries: smallholder purchases from formal channels run from 5% for common beans in Zambia to 80% for hybrid maize in Kenya. Improved maize varieties can yield up to six tonnes a hectare against 1.8 for home saved seed, according to a 2022 account. A Malawi study cautions that formal reforms have had mixed results and that supporting both formal and informal systems works better than replacing one. Kenya’s avocado growers show the quality problem: certification records are hard to check, so cheaper uncertified seedlings are common, according to the World Bank’s 2026 diagnostic.
Per cent. PARI; a South African review in PMC and Mail and Guardian; Sperling dataset (2015); DAI summary of formal purchases by crop and country. Estimates differ in crops and years, so read as a spread
Maize yield, tonnes per hectare. Mail and Guardian (2022), with improved seed shown as “up to”; actual yields depend on soil, rainfall and management
Pest management: protect what is grown
If pests take up to 40% of crops, protection is a land saving measure. African evidence includes push pull farming, where on farm comparisons across Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania found climate adapted fields losing about 5% of maize to stemborers while neighbours lost about 40%, though these are not randomised trials. The SIANI review of agrobiologicals adds that biological products work best inside integrated pest management and can cut residues for export markets, but face slow registration and variable field performance. Kenya’s regulators and eight East African states are moving to simplify approvals, as the framework presented in October shows.
Machines: services, not just tractors
FAO data show sub Saharan Africa with under two tractors per 1,000 hectares of cropland, against about ten in South Asia and Latin America. About 70% of farmers cultivate plots under two hectares by hoe. The history is cautionary: FAO has said past state and donor mechanisation efforts failed, and most of 30 schemes set up before 1980 collapsed. IFPRI’s review finds hiring markets that serve small farmers, common in Asia, are underdeveloped in Africa, partly because scattered plots raise servicing costs, and notes new SMS and app platforms for tractor hire in Ghana, Nigeria and Kenya. The practical lesson is to measure what matters, such as hectares prepared in the planting window and uptime, not tractors delivered.
Tractors per 1,000 hectares of cropland. FAO figures as cited by the PARI programme (Birner and Daum); approximate
Advice: reach is not the same as results
Ethiopia has one of the world’s largest extension systems, about 43 development agents per 10,000 farmers in 2016/17, up from 21 in 2010, and reaches over 75% of farm households. Yet yields and technology adoption remain low, which led the government and Digital Green to test video mediated extension in a randomised trial covering 2,345 households in 342 villages. More broadly, a review in Science found that mobile delivered agricultural information raised yields by about 4%, and noted that farmer to extension worker ratios exceed 1,000 to 1 in many countries. The message is that advice works when it is timely, local and two way, and that more agents alone do not guarantee more output.
Davis et al. (2010) as shown in IFPRI and Ethiopian Development Research Institute material; Ethiopia’s 2016/17 figure from IFPRI. Years differ across countries
Integration as an organisational lever
Star South Group offers a business side response to uncertainty. Founded 23 years ago as a fruit wholesaler, it now operates through a Dutch holding company with offices in the Netherlands, Cyprus and South Africa, and owns table grape farms near Augrabies and Robertson and pomegranate production near Wellington. Its managing director says own production makes it a producer informed commercial partner and gives control over timing, varieties, quality, traceability and packing. It works with about 200 hectares of pomegranates in Wellington and another 400 hectares nationally, expects annual volumes above 7,500 tonnes, and aims to represent close to 50% of South Africa’s exportable pomegranate volume by 2029. It also runs an academy offering learnerships and farm worker training. These are company statements.
Our diagram of Star South’s model as described by the company in FreshPlaza, 22 October 2026
Context helps. The Pomegranate Association of South Africa reported 1,167 hectares planted in early 2025 after 25% growth over five years, and industry voices expect volumes to roughly double between 2025 and 2030 as new orchards mature, with one exporter warning of a likely price impact. On our arithmetic the company’s 600 hectares equals about half of that early-2025 total, though plantings have grown since and the figures come from different dates. What the article does not say is how smallholders fit in. The World Bank’s Kenya diagnostic describes how vertically integrated large farms in avocado can meet export standards, while fragmented smallholders struggle with traceability and brokers. The integrated model shows how traceability can be built in, and also why cooperatives need their own way to prove quality.
Where verified field data fits
Whether the goal is to meet land based climate targets, qualify for export buyers or secure finance, the common need is verified evidence that output rose on existing land. AgriKonnekt is built to check farm plots with sensors and satellites so cooperatives can show results to funders, according to the AgriKonnekt page. We have not seen it used to verify yield intensification or avoided land use change, so that application is our proposal.
What to do next
- Governments negotiating climate finance should count farm emission cuts, yield gains and ecosystem protection as land saving measures alongside energy crops.
- Seed programmes should support both formal supply and the informal channels where most seed is sourced, and keep certification records farmers can check.
- Cooperatives should invest in pest management that protects existing yields, using integrated approaches and, where registered, biological products.
- Mechanisation programmes should back hiring services and measure timely hectares, uptime and yield, not machine counts.
- Extension providers should combine agents with phone based, two way advice and track whether farmers act on it.
- Policymakers should review land deals against actual production before approving new ones.
What we can and cannot claim
| Statement | Evidence status |
|---|---|
| 66 versus 267 million hectares for biomass by 2050 | PIK study as reported by Down To Earth; paper not read |
| Pests destroy up to 40% of global production | FAO figure as reported; applies globally, not to Africa alone |
| 70% to 90% of African seed is informal | Estimates vary by source, crop and year |
| Improved seed can yield up to six tonnes against 1.8 | Single 2022 account; an upper bound |
| Under 2 tractors per 1,000 hectares | FAO figure via PARI; date not stated in the source |
| Mobile advice raised yields about 4% | Science review of meta analyses; modest and context dependent |
| 11% of contracted land confirmed in production | Land Matrix tally from 2014 to 2016; global, not current |
| Star South aims for 50% of exportable pomegranates by 2029 | Company statement; not independently verified |
The land squeeze makes one point inescapable for Africa: output must rise from the land farmers already have, and the levers for doing so are known even if the evidence for each is mixed. Better seed, better pest control, shared machinery and advice that farmers can act on all raise yields, but only where the system around them works, as the failed tractor schemes and the stalled land deals show. Business models such as Star South’s show one way to build quality and traceability into a supply chain, and cooperatives can build their own through records, shared services and verified field data. The countries and organisations that treat land as the scarce input it has become, and measure results on actual plots, will be best placed to feed their people and meet their climate goals at the same time.
Sources & notes
SOURCES: Shagun, The land sector can help meet climate goals, if countries get the balance right, Down To Earth (12 November 2026); DTE Staff, FAO unveils farming guide to help smallholders increase yields with fewer resources, Down To Earth (12 November 2026); FreshPlaza, Entrepreneurial exporter builds a more resilient agribusiness through integration; FAO, Optimization and Minimization: Towards Sustainable Plant Production; PARI, Innovations for food and nutrition security (seeds); Mail and Guardian, Time to fix seed systems; Louise Sperling, Nothing less than a seed revolution; DAI, four recommendations for strengthening seed systems; Informal and formal seed systems in Malawi; Daum and Birner on mechanisation; Farmer’s Weekly on IFPRI’s mechanisation report; Abate et al., video extension in Ethiopia; IFPRI on Ethiopia’s extension system; EDRI, extension services and productivity; Fabregas et al., Science, 2019; GIGA Focus on agrofuels and land deals; Future Agricultures, biofuels boom and bust in Africa; Timothy Wise, The great land giveaway in Mozambique; FreshPlaza on South African pomegranate exports; FreshPlaza on pomegranate volumes; AgriKonnekt.
Differences between sources: informal seed share is 70% to 90% depending on source and crop; Ethiopia’s extension ratio is 21 per 10,000 in 2010 and 43 in 2016/17; Star South’s hectares come from the company, while the national total is from POMASA in early 2025.
Our own arithmetic: the 89% remainder of contracted land; the comparison of 600 hectares with 1,167 hectares.
Not read: the PIK paper, the FAO guide, the video extension trial results and the Land Matrix database. Company claims are Star South’s own.