On 21 October 2026, Farmer’s Weekly reported from a two day conservation agriculture research forum at North West University’s Pienaarskamp farm in Potchefstroom, co hosted with ASSET Research and the Agricultural Research Council and mostly funded by the Maize Trust. The setting is South African commercial grain farming, but the questions it raised travel well across the continent: should a farmer fix what a plant shows, or the balance beneath it? Is conservation agriculture one tool or a whole system? And who pays for the trials that tell a farmer what works on their own land? This article reads the forum alongside African evidence, from Nairobi’s fertiliser summit to Kenya’s soil laboratories, to ask what it means for cooperatives and the farmers in them.
Read this first. We read the Farmer’s Weekly report in full. We did not attend the forum and report only what the article says. Wider evidence comes from published research, African Union material and Kenyan press coverage, and several figures reach us through news coverage rather than the underlying reports. Where sources differ, we show both. Research stops at 11 November 2026.
Six findings
- Balance beats volume. The forum’s soil nutrient workshop argued that crop quality depends more on nutrient ratios than on how much fertiliser goes down, because one nutrient in excess can block another.
- Africa is under fertilised on average, but averages hide the real problem. Use is about 18 kg of nutrients per hectare against a 50 kg target set in 2006 and a world average of about 135 kg.
- Diagnosis is the missing step. KALRO’s survey found 63% of 231 Kenyan sites below pH 5.5, where fertiliser works poorly.
- Conservation agriculture is not no till. Africa wide evidence shows a small average yield gain of 3.7%, stronger when all three principles are applied together.
- Adoption is thin. Only 1.1% of African cropland was under conservation agriculture in 2015/16, against 12.5% worldwide.
- Trials are the bridge. The forum’s chair funds his own trials, which shows both how valuable and how costly farm level evidence is.
Balance before volume
The first day’s workshop covered DRiS, a method that analyses the chemistry of the plant and its soil together. Its commercial director argued that waiting for visible deficiency is expensive, since by then correction may be too late, and that a symptom often comes from imbalance rather than shortage. ASSET Research now runs soil health analysis in all its trials this way. Soil from eight on farm trials in the 2025/26 season, plus commercial farms across the Mpumalanga Highveld, the Free State and North West, fed the discussion. DRiS says it has cleaned data from three provinces, 15 areas and 34 localities, about 200 complete composite samples. That is a modest dataset, and its figures are the developers’ own.
For African agriculture the principle matters because most of the continent faces the opposite headline: too little fertiliser, not too much. The African Union Commission told the 2024 Nairobi summit that use stands at about 18 kg per hectare, less than half the target set in Abuja in 2006. The AU’s own opening notes put the rise at 8 kg to below 25 kg and note that 22 countries use under 10 kg, so estimates differ by source and year. Africa accounts for only about 3% of the world’s inorganic fertiliser use, according to Uganda’s Independent reporting on the summit. The Nairobi Declaration responded by pledging to triple use, and by urging digital data and tools so that fertiliser is matched to crop, soil and climate, which is the DRiS idea at continental scale.
Kilograms of nutrients per hectare. Africa 2006 and the Abuja target: African Union; Africa 2022 and world average: summit coverage (the world figure is about 120 kg in other reports)
Kenya shows why diagnosis comes first
Kenya’s numbers explain why a volume target alone is risky. A KALRO survey of 231 sites, reported by the Nation, found every soil tested below pH 7 and 63% below pH 5.5, the point where acidity begins to limit nutrient uptake. A separate Nation report says KALRO analysis finds nearly 63% of Kenya’s arable land acidic. Farmers who apply blanket fertiliser to acid soil can spend heavily for little return. One Nation report describes a Western Kenya farmer whose soil needed lime and organic matter, not the subsidised compound fertiliser, and reports about Sh19 billion in subsidies that often go out without confirming the fertiliser matches soil needs.
KALRO survey of 231 sites as reported by the Nation (2026). The 37% share is our arithmetic
Policy is moving. KALRO began digitised soil sampling in 45 counties in early 2025, and in September 2026 the Agriculture Cabinet Secretary asked it to keep analysing about 77,000 samples and publish county level fertility maps, while launching a National Soil Laboratory Network and a National Soil Partnership. The Ministry also intends to link soil results to KIAMIS, where over 8 million farmers are registered, so that subsidy support can eventually reflect what each soil needs, according to the Kenya News Agency. A Nation commentary calls the draft Kenya Fertiliser and Soil Health Action Plan 2026 to 2035 the first official acknowledgement that the problem is diagnosis, with mandatory soil testing proposed. We have not read the plan itself. Whether farmers will use the results is the open question, and an agri tech founder’s claim that 98% of Kenyan farmers do not test their soil is his own estimate.
Conservation agriculture is a system, not one tool
The forum’s chair, a Free State grain farmer who began experimenting in 2006, stressed that conservation agriculture is not the same as no till. It combines crop rotation, soil cover and, where it fits, integrated livestock, with tillage chosen to suit the soil. The evidence supports him. A global meta analysis of 5,463 comparisons from 610 studies found that no till alone cut yields by an average of 5.7%, with losses smaller when residue retention and rotation came with it. Africa focused work is more modest still. A meta analysis in Nature Food, using 933 observations from 16 sub Saharan countries, found conservation systems raised yields by 3.7% on average, significantly only for maize at about 4%, with stronger results when all three principles were applied, in drier conditions and where herbicides were used.
Average yield change relative to conventional tillage. Global figure: Pittelkow et al., Nature, 2015. Africa figures: Corbeels et al., Nature Food, 2020. The studies use different comparisons, so read the bars as direction, not a ranking
The commentary on the African study explains why small gains rarely change a smallholder’s mind: reduced tillage raises weed pressure, herbicides can be out of reach, manual weeding lands on women’s labour, poor markets discourage legume rotations, and residues are often needed as animal feed. That matches the forum chair’s point that practices must be tested farm by farm and that a neighbour’s result is a guide, not a substitute.
Africa’s footprint is small and uneven
Estimates collected by FAO linked researchers put Africa’s conservation agriculture area at about 1.2 million hectares in 2013, led by South Africa, Zimbabwe and Zambia, with Kenya at about 32,000 hectares. The country figures come from 2009 and 2013 and are dated. They are the most consistent set we found, not a current count.
Thousand hectares. Kassam et al. 2015 as shown in a CCARDESA presentation by Thierfelder; Malawi and Zimbabwe are 2013 estimates, the rest 2009. Not current
The wider picture is stark. Conservation agriculture grew worldwide from about 157 million hectares in 2013 to 205.4 million in 2018/19, or 14.7% of global cropland, according to Kassam, Friedrich and Derpsch. Africa lagged: an Africa focused study cites only 1.1% of the continent’s cropland under conservation agriculture in 2015/16, against 12.5% worldwide that season, about eleven times lower by our arithmetic.
Columns: million hectares (left axis). Line: share of global cropland (right axis; no share was in our source for 2013). Mkomwa et al. 2017; Kassam et al. 2022
Why does awareness not turn into adoption? A study of 4,373 households and 278 focus groups in Malawi, Zambia and Zimbabwe found gaps between awareness, training and demonstration on one side and actual adoption on the other, and named declining soil fertility as a major maize constraint in Zambia and Malawi, with drought and heat more pronounced in Zimbabwe. The forum’s model answers part of this: trials in the farmers’ own region, run with researchers, give evidence that is local rather than borrowed.
Who pays for the evidence?
The forum’s chair is conducting a large trial at his own expense, has bought a dedicated tractor, planter and sprayer so it does not disrupt production fields, and says reliable results need consistent management and years of commitment. Most African farmers cannot do that, and cooperatives are well placed to share the cost: one trial, many members, one dataset. But a trial is only useful to others, and to funders, if the results can be trusted. That is where verification enters. AgriKonnekt is built to check farm plots with sensors and satellites so that cooperatives can show results to funders, as described on the AgriKonnekt page. We have not seen it tested on soil nutrient balance, so the link to DRiS style diagnosis is our proposal, not an existing feature.
What to do next
- Test before you buy. Take a soil sample to a KALRO linked laboratory or a county soil programme before choosing fertiliser, and ask about lime where acidity is suspected.
- Read ratios, not just totals. Ask for analyses that show nutrient balance, and treat a single high value as a possible cause of problems, not a sign of health.
- Adopt conservation agriculture as a package. Start with rotation and soil cover where residues are not needed for feed, and treat no till as optional.
- Run a small trial in your own region. Split a field, keep records for several seasons and compare yield and net income, not yield alone.
- Pool trials in cooperatives. Share costs and data, agree one protocol and keep records that a funder can verify.
- Ask counties and ministries to publish soil maps and to link subsidy to soil results, as Kenya has said it intends to do.
What we can and cannot claim
| Statement | Evidence status |
|---|---|
| The forum took place with the co hosts and funder described | Reported by Farmer’s Weekly; we did not attend |
| DRiS has about 200 composite samples from 34 localities | The developer’s statement as reported; not independently checked |
| Africa uses about 18 kg of fertiliser nutrients per hectare | African Union statement; other AU material says below 25 kg |
| 63% of 231 Kenyan sites were below pH 5.5 | KALRO survey as reported by the Nation; we did not read the survey |
| Conservation systems raised African yields by 3.7% on average | Corbeels et al., via a Nature Food commentary; we did not read the full paper |
| Only 1.1% of African cropland was under conservation agriculture in 2015/16 | Cited in a Zambia study that attributes it to Kassam et al. 2019; not checked at source |
| Cooperatives could share trial costs and data | Our argument; not tested here |
Closing
The forum’s deepest lesson is humility: treat soils as a system, test on your own land and trust data you can check. Africa’s soils are acid, thin and diverse, its fertiliser use is low and its conservation agriculture is still small, so guessing is more costly here than almost anywhere. Kenya’s soil laboratories and fertility maps, the Nairobi Declaration’s call for digital tools and cooperatives that can pool trials and verify results point to the same answer: measure first, then spend, then show your results. Farmers who can do that will use inputs better, and will be easier for lenders and funders to back.
Sources & notes
SOURCES: Farmer’s Weekly, Joint research forum digs deep into conservation, regenerative agriculture (21 October 2026); Pittelkow et al., Nature, global no till meta analysis; Nature Food commentary on Corbeels et al. 2020; African Union Commission, Africa Fertilizer and Soil Health Summit opening, 9 May 2024; African Union, day one opening remarks; The Independent (Uganda) on the Nairobi pledge; Down To Earth on fertiliser disparities; Nation, What our soils have been telling us; Nation, Farmers turn to compost and crop rotation; Nation, Is AI the answer to Kenya’s soil crisis?; Kenya News Agency on soil health; Kassam, Friedrich and Derpsch, Agronomy, 2022; Mkomwa et al., Conservation Agriculture in Africa: An Overview; Thierfelder, CCARDESA presentation; Kirui and Tambo, Zambia study; Tufa et al., Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 2023; AgriKonnekt.
Differences between sources: African fertiliser use is about 18 kg per hectare per the AU Commission, below 25 kg in other AU material; the world average is about 135 kg in one report and about 120 kg in another; country conservation agriculture areas mix 2009 and 2013 estimates.
Our own arithmetic: the 37% share of Kenyan soils between pH 5.5 and 7; the eleven fold gap between the world and African shares.
Not read: the full Corbeels paper, the KALRO survey, Kenya’s draft action plan and the DRiS data. Company and developer claims are as stated by them.