Close
Climate Finance

Carbon deals alone cannot close Africa’s farm adaptation gap

(10 min read)

The second week of COP31 produced four signals that matter to African farms. A first draft decision proposes raising annual adaptation finance for developing countries to at least 120 billion dollars by 2035. An African delegate told Anadolu that no one knows what tripling adaptation finance means in practice, and Climate Analytics’ Bill Hare called the finance agenda totally blocked. Kenya and Singapore signed a carbon trading agreement. And a Daily Star commentary argued that Bangladesh deserves recognition for adaptation solutions as well as finance. Read together, they ask who pays for adaptation, how much reaches the farm, and who decides how it is spent.

Africa’s adaptation bill is larger than the offer

African leaders put the continent’s adaptation needs at nearly 84 billion dollars a year in the Addis Ababa Declaration of September 2025, against flows of 14 billion dollars in 2021 and 2022. The Global Center on Adaptation’s estimate based on national climate plans is 53 billion dollars a year, and it warns that the true figure may be twice that. The African Group of Negotiators has put it at 65 to 86.5 billion dollars a year up to 2030.

Africa’s estimated adaptation need is four to seven times its flows

Annual adaptation finance estimates for Africa in US dollars, billions, against flows, Addis Ababa Declaration, Global Center on Adaptation and the African Group of Negotiators. Years and methods differ

0306090120GCA from NDCs: 53 billion dollars a year53Global Center onAdaptation, from NDCsAfrican Group of Negotiators: 65 to 86.5 billion dollars a year65 to 86.5African Groupof NegotiatorsAddis Ababa Declaration: 84 billion dollars a year84Addis AbabaDeclaration 2025GCA: more than 100 billion dollars a year100GCA, if NDCsunderstate by halfCurrent adaptation flows to Africa: about $14bn a year in 2021 and 2022

Set against the global numbers, the draft is modest. UNEP’s Adaptation Gap Report 2025 puts developing countries’ need at 310 billion dollars a year by 2035 on modelled costs, while international public flows were 26 billion dollars in 2023, down from 28 billion a year earlier. A draft of at least 120 billion dollars would cover about 39% of the modelled need, and an African delegate put it nearer 30% on other estimates. A lower figure of 100 billion dollars is also under discussion, and developed countries have not agreed on either.

The COP31 draft offer covers about two fifths of the modelled need

Annual adaptation finance for developing countries: 2023 public flows and modelled 2035 need from UNEP, draft options reported by Anadolu. The African delegate quoted puts the draft at about 30% of need

0100200300Public international flows: 26 billion dollars26Public flows 2023Lower option in talks: 100 billion dollars100Lower optionDraft: at least 120 billion by 2035: 120 billion dollars120COP31 draft textUNEP modelled need: 310 billion dollars310Modelled need 2035US dollars, billions a year. The draft covers 39% of the modelled need, our arithmetic (120 over 310)
Public adaptation finance fell as the Glasgow target drew near

International public adaptation finance to developing countries, UNEP Adaptation Gap Report 2025. The Glasgow Climate Pact goal doubles 2019 levels to 40 billion dollars by 2025

01020304050202019282022262023402025Glasgow targetInternational public adaptation finance, US dollars, billions. The 2019 base of 20 is our arithmetic, half of 40

Hare’s warning explains the stakes. He told Anadolu that every extra tenth of a degree of warming makes adaptation costlier and less effective, so delay raises the bill. The delegate’s call for a baseline that defines tripling is practical: without one, no farmer or finance ministry can tell whether the money has arrived.

Farms get a sliver of the adaptation money

Agriculture is the largest single recipient of adaptation finance in Africa, with about 26% or 3.4 billion dollars a year according to Global Center on Adaptation estimates reported by Mongabay. Climate Focus puts the need of Africa’s smallholders, who farm 10 hectares or less, at about 71 billion dollars a year, roughly 21 times that sum. Family Farmers for Climate Action counts about 810 million dollars of international climate finance reaching small scale agriculture worldwide.

Agriculture receives about a quarter of Africa’s adaptation money

Share of annual adaptation finance going to agriculture in Africa, Global Center on Adaptation estimates reported by Mongabay in December 2025

Agriculture: 26%Other sectors: 74%26%to agricultureAgriculture, about $3.4bn a year26%All other sectors, our arithmetic74%Share of adaptation finance to Africa,Global Center on Adaptation estimate
Smallholder adaptation needs dwarf what reaches them

Estimated annual need of Africa’s smallholders on 10 hectares or less (Climate Focus), finance to agriculture (Global Center on Adaptation) and international finance to small scale agriculture worldwide (Family Farmers for Climate Action), via Mongabay

020406080Need for 65 million smallholdersNeed for 65 million smallholders: $71bn a year$71bnAgriculture adaptation finance, AfricaAgriculture adaptation finance, Africa: $3.4bn a year$3.4bnInternational finance to small farms, worldInternational finance to small farms, world: $0.81bn a year$0.81bnUS dollars, billions a year. The need is about 21 times agriculture’s current finance, our arithmetic (71 over 3.4)

Where the money lands matters as much as the total. The Global Center on Adaptation and the Climate Policy Initiative found that 54% of adaptation flows to Africa go to ten countries, while the ten smallest recipients receive 1%, and that private investors have financed less than 3% of adaptation. A ward or a county that sits in a small recipient country needs a channel that does not depend on those averages.

Ten countries take over half of Africa’s adaptation flows

Distribution of adaptation finance flows among African countries, Global Center on Adaptation and Climate Policy Initiative, State and Trends in Climate Adaptation Finance 2023. The 45% is our arithmetic

Ten countries: 54%Top 10 recipients54%Other countries: 45%Other African countries45%, our arithmeticBottom 10 countries: 1%Bottom 10 recipients: 1%Adaptation finance flows to African countriesShare of the total. Rectangle areas are proportional

Carbon deals open a channel, not a solution

Kenya and Singapore signed an Implementation Agreement on 16 November under Article 6.2 of the Paris Agreement, a government to government framework for transferring carbon credits. Kenya becomes the third African country to sign one with Singapore after Ghana in May 2024 and Rwanda in May 2025, and it is Singapore’s 13th such agreement. On 14 November Singapore authorised its first project under the Rwanda agreement. Reports on the Kenya text say Singapore will direct 5% of proceeds from authorised credits to adaptation in Kenya and that project applications are expected to open in 2027. Under Article 6 the host country must account for transferred credits in its own reported emissions.

The agreement is a real source of new money, and it also shows the limits of carbon revenue as an adaptation fund. On the reported 5% share, every 100 dollars of credit sales yields 5 dollars for adaptation. Covering the 70 billion dollar gap between Africa’s 84 billion dollar need and 14 billion dollars of flows would take 1.4 trillion dollars of credit sales. Carbon revenue can complement grant based finance, but it cannot replace the obligation developed countries accepted under Article 9.1, which is what the African delegate meant by accountability.

Local control is the part Africa can start now

The Daily Star commentary describes what Bangladesh built with sustained public investment: more than 4,200 cyclone shelters and an early warning network of over 76,000 volunteers, floating vegetable gardens for flooded areas, and a solar irrigation initiative of 641 pumps, 357 of them connected to the grid so that farmers sell surplus power. Its February 2026 Framework and Action Plan for Locally Led Adaptation rests on the principle that communities facing risk should help decide how adaptation money is used. Yet Bangladesh’s ministry says it has about 4 billion dollars against a yearly need of 8.5 billion, so even a leader in local adaptation covers roughly 47% of its bill.

Bangladesh covers about half its yearly adaptation bill

Annual adaptation needs and available financing as stated by Bangladesh’s environment ministry at an international meeting in November 2026. The gap and the share covered (47%) are our arithmetic

0510Need: 8.5 billion dollars8.5Available: about 4 billion dollars-4Gap: 4.5 billion dollars4.5Annual adaptation needFinancing availableGap, our arithmeticUS dollars, billions a year. Bangladesh’s environment ministry, November 2026

Kenya has a comparable structure. Under the Financing Locally Led Climate Action programme, ward committees set priorities and county funds pay for them. By the COP29 talks in late 2024, Kshs12.68 billion had reached 45 counties and 1,418 wards, and by April 2026 all 47 counties had enacted Climate Change Fund laws. The programme can absorb more money if funders trust it.

Three actions follow. African negotiators and funders should press for a defined baseline for tripling and a grant based share reserved for smallholder groups. Kenya should publish how the 5% adaptation share from carbon sales will reach county climate funds and ward committees before applications open in 2027. County governments should pair solar irrigation and early warning with farm level records, so that finance follows measured need. AgriKonnekt, a digital registry, finance, delivery and monitoring platform for smallholder groups in Kenya that checks plots with satellites and sensors, gives these partners the member, plot and repayment records they need to target and verify support.

Negotiators in Antalya will leave with a number, and farmers will measure it by whether a pump, a warning or a grant reaches their ward. If the figure is defined, carbon revenue is added to grants rather than replacing them, and wards decide how the money is used, then adaptation becomes a farm investment. If not, the gap that African leaders named in Addis will remain, and smallholders will keep paying for climate shocks themselves.

Sources & notes

SOURCES: The Daily Star, What the world can learn from Bangladesh’s climate innovations (17 November 2026); Anadolu, African countries say 1st draft from COP31 conference risks distraction from climate finance accountability (16 November 2026); Anadolu, COP31 climate finance agenda totally blocked, climate expert says (18 November 2026); Nation, Kenya and Singapore sign carbon trading deal (16 November 2026); Africa Adaptation Initiative, ACS2 adaptation emerges as a priority (2025); Global Center on Adaptation and Climate Policy Initiative, State and Trends in Climate Adaptation Finance (2023); Global Center on Adaptation, Accelerating Adaptation Finance (2023); UNECA, CCDA-XI report and outcome statement; Mongabay, Africa mulls gap in climate adaptation finance for agriculture (2025); UNEP, Adaptation Gap Report 2025; Africa Sustainability Matters, Singapore signs 13th Implementation Agreement with Kenya; Technode Global, Singapore deepens Article 6 partnerships with Kenya and Colombia; CarbonCredits.com, Singapore approves first Rwanda carbon project under Article 6; Serrari Group, Kenya and Singapore carbon trading agreement; The Standard, FLLoCA at COP29 (2024); The Standard, Kenya secures World Bank funding (April 2026). Differences between sources: the Africa need estimates cover different years and methods (the Global Center’s 53 billion dollars is from national climate plans to 2035, the African Group’s range runs to 2030, and the Addis figure is a political declaration), so the columns show the range of estimates and not a single trend; the Anadolu delegate’s 30% and our 39% use different needs estimates; the 5% adaptation share and the 2027 application date in the Kenya agreement come from Serrari Group’s report and not from the published text; the 26% share of agriculture and the 71 billion dollar need come from different organisations; the Bangladesh figures are ministry statements reported by the Daily Star; the 2019 point on the line is derived from the Glasgow goal. Our own arithmetic: a gap of 70 billion dollars for Africa (84 less 14), and an adaptation need of about 4 to 7 times flows (53, 84 and 100 over 14); the draft covering 39% of modelled need (120 over 310); the 21 times difference between smallholder need and agriculture finance (71 over 3.4); 74% to other sectors (100 less 26); 45% to other African countries (100 less 54 less 1); Bangladesh’s gap of 4.5 billion dollars (8.5 less 4) and 47% coverage (4 over 8.5); 1.4 trillion dollars of credit sales to yield 70 billion dollars at 5% (70 over 0.05); a 2019 base of 20 billion dollars (40 over 2).