Close
Climate Finance

Smallholders need credit systems that read informal data

(20 min read)

COP31 closes in Antalya on 20 November, and the pledges made there will land on farms that mostly sit outside the formal economy. By the International Labour Organization’s 2018 count, almost all agricultural work in Sub Saharan Africa is informal, so a lender built for payslips, land titles and bank statements cannot see it. This article asks why credit systems miss the data a farm already produces, what mobile money, power and policy have changed, and what lenders, cooperatives and platforms must build next. It draws on the newsletters we were sent, on NextBillion’s argument that credit is a system design problem, and on studies from across Africa published before them.

Read this first. We read the pasted newsletters in full and the abstracts, summaries or press pages of every outside source, not the full studies. The ILO figures date from 2018 and the agri SME finance estimates from about 2022, so today’s values may differ. The Ghana results come from one lender and one crop region, so they show how design and timing matter, not what every farm will see. Mission 300 figures are as reported by its partners and the press. The newsletters were sent in June and July, so we treat their dated calls and deadlines as past. Research stops at 17 November 2026.

Six findings

  • Farming is the most informal work. About 98% of agricultural jobs in Sub Saharan Africa are informal, against 70% in services.
  • The gap sits in the middle. Formal channels meet about a third of agri SME finance demand, leaving $106 billion across Sub Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia.
  • Mobile money built a trail. 40% of adults in Sub Saharan Africa held a mobile money account in 2024, up from 27% in 2021.
  • Design beats data. Informal borrowers already generate signals. Lenders’ systems cannot link or interpret them.
  • Timing decided a Ghana trial. About a quarter of borrowers got inputs on time. Spending rose 11% and average output and profit did not move significantly.
  • Power and storage are part of the credit case. Mission 300 has connected more than 50 million people, and perishables lose up to 56% after harvest.

The informal farm is the norm

The ILO found in 2018 that 85.8% of employment in Africa is informal, and that agriculture is the most informal sector worldwide, at more than 90%. A summary of the same data for Sub Saharan Africa puts agricultural employment at 97.9%, against 77.4% in industry and 70.2% in services, and women at 89.7% against 82.7% for men. The data are old and they count jobs, not farms, but the direction is plain.

Informal employment in Africa

ILO data (2018), as reported. Share of all employment

Informal: 85.8%85.8%Formal (our arithmetic): 14.2%14.2%Informal employment: 85.8%Formal employment: 14.2%, our arithmetic
Informal share by sector

ILO data (2018) summarised by INCLUDE, Sub Saharan Africa

0%25%50%75%100%Agriculture: 97.9%97.9%AgricultureIndustry: 77.4%77.4%IndustryServices: 70.2%70.2%ServicesAll employment: 85.8%85.8%All employmentShare of employment that is informal. ILO data (2018) as summarised by INCLUDE; the figures are old

Informal does not mean outside finance. The World Economic Forum, citing the Global Findex 2025, says adults in low and middle income economies were twice as likely to borrow from informal sources such as family, savings groups and moneylenders as from banks, and that about 500 million people save in informal groups. These are working credit systems. They simply leave no record a bank can read.

The gap sits in the middle

ISF Advisors and the CASA programme estimate that agri SMEs in Sub Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia want about $160 billion in finance, and that formal channels supply about $54 billion, a third. COLEAD, drawing on that work, puts the annual gap for agri MSMEs in Sub Saharan Africa alone at $74 billion, with the sharpest need between $50,000 and $1 million, the missing middle. Nationally, IFC put Nigeria’s MSME finance gap at $32.2 billion and named agriculture and trade, largely informal, among the most underserved sectors. IFC’s 2018 estimate for Kenya was $19 billion, and $331 billion for African SMEs overall.

The agri SME finance gap

ISF Advisors and CASA via AgriLinks. US$ billions a year

050100150Demand: US$160 billion160Met by formal finance: US$54 billion−54Gap: US$106 billion106Agri-SMEdemandMet byformal financeRemaininggapUS$ billions a year. ISF Advisors and CASA via AgriLinks; Sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia together

NextBillion’s newsletter featured IFC’s SME Growth Accelerator, which offers $50,000 to $1.5 million, mentoring and networks to small and medium enterprises across emerging markets, not only farms. Its application window closed on 15 November, two days ago. Its size shows where programmes already aim, and why the band below it needs lenders who can read ordinary, informal firms.

Mobile money built a trail

The Global Findex 2025 reports that 40% of adults in Sub Saharan Africa had a mobile money account in 2024, up from 27% in 2021 and 11% in 2014. That now exceeds the 38% with bank accounts. Account ownership of any kind rose from 49% to 58%, and formal saving rose 12 points to 35%. About 60% still have no mobile money account, and roughly a quarter of adults without any account already hold a phone, an ID and a registered SIM card, the prerequisites. Only about half of mobile money owners protect their phones with a password, which matters when the phone becomes the credit file.

Sub Saharan Africa gained accounts, wallets and savings

Global Findex 2025. Share of adults, 2021 and 2024

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%Any account, 2021: 49%Any account, 2024: 58%49%58% Any accountMobile money account, 2021: 27%Mobile money account, 2024: 40%27%40% Mobile money accountFormal saving, 2021: 23%Formal saving, 2024: 35%23%35% Formal saving20212024Global Findex 2025, Sub-Saharan Africa. The 2021 formal saving point isour arithmetic from the reported 12-point rise
Mobile money is speeding up

Global Findex 2025. Mobile money accounts, share of adults

Adults with a mobile money account, left axis (%)Points gained a year, right axis0102030405001234562014: 11%11%20142021: 27%27%20212024: 40%40%20242014 to 2021: 2.3 points a year+2.3 a year2021 to 2024: 4.3 points a year+4.3 a yearPace is the average gain between survey years: 16 points over 7 years, then 13 points over 3 yearsGlobal Findex 2025 via FXC Intelligence and the World Bank. The yearly pace is our arithmetic

A trail is not a score, and a score is not credit.

More data is not the answer

Ayokunmi Sodamola, writing in NextBillion on 30 June about building the lending platform Recova, argues that the gap is not poor financial behaviour or a lack of data. Informal borrowers generate signals across mobile wallets, bank accounts, savings clubs and merchants, but in formats and across channels that lenders’ systems cannot tie to an identity or interpret. Income swings, normal in informal work, are read as risk. His answer is to treat data, identity, trust, risk and incentives as linked layers of one system.

Five layers of a credit system, read for the farm

Sodamola, NextBillion. Farm examples are our reading

DataSales, mobile money,plot recordsIdentityPhone, ID, groupmembershipTrustSavings group,buyer historyRiskSeasonal incomeread as normalIncentivesInputs on time,repay at harvestLayers from Sodamola (NextBillion, 30 June 2026). The farm examples under each are our reading

Evidence from Africa points the same way. In Tanzania’s Kilombero, FSD Tanzania describes a data first pilot with Black Swan in which women’s enterprises, with phones, accounts and records often in a husband’s name, stayed invisible to lenders. The lesson it draws is that rural credit fails at the point of understanding more than at the point of lending. In Kenya, the Farmers Credit Scoring Model built by Pathways Technologies, with EU and German support through the Data Governance in Africa Initiative, scores crop yields, market sales and payment behaviour in a country where fewer than one in five smallholders hold formal credit, according to BMZ Digital Global. McKinsey’s older framework names what any score must estimate: identity, ability to repay and willingness to repay. A farm aware system reads each in the farm’s own terms. In Madagascar, a discrete choice experiment with 420 smallholders found a higher willingness to pay for digital credit than for conventional credit.

Our World in Data’s brief offers a related warning. Lant Pritchett argues that one low poverty line splits the world into poor and not poor, and with Martina Viarengo proposes a higher line of $20 to $40 a day; OWID’s founder Max Roser arrives at $30. Credit has its own binary: formal or informal. Our reading is that a farm which is neither destitute nor documented falls out of both.

What a Ghana trial teaches about timing

Dean Karlan, Monica Lambon Quayefio, Utsav Manjeer and Christopher Udry ran a randomised trial with 1,372 smallholder farmers in Ghana’s Ashanti cocoa region, published in the Journal of Development Economics in 2026. Farmerline scored applicants on farm characteristics, production records and sales histories, with no collateral, and 62% of applicants were eligible. Eligible farmers were offered inputs on credit of up to about 350 cedis, roughly $75 in 2018, with repayment starting three months after receipt. Only 59% of those assigned to credit ultimately received a loan, and about 75% of borrowers got inputs later than planned.

Farmers offered credit raised input spending by about 11%, including on complementary inputs such as hired machinery. They did not raise output or profit significantly on average. The spending rise was driven entirely by men. Women, about a third of the sample, spent less on inputs. The working paper adds a cautious, non randomised comparison: farmers whose loans arrived on time spent significantly more on fertiliser and relied less on informal credit. One author, speaking to VoxDev, put the lesson as digital credit being no silver bullet: complementary pieces matter.

When the inputs arrived

J-PAL summary of the Ghana trial. Borrowers only

Later than planned: about 75%On time: about 25%75%lateInputs arrived later than planned: about 75%Inputs arrived on time: about 25%Share of borrowers who received loans. J-PAL summary of Karlan, Lambon-Quayefio, Manjeer and Udry

Late delivery is partly a road problem. The World Bank’s 3 July newsletter says road transport accounts for roughly 80% of Africa’s imported fuel use and that transport can be up to 45% of the final retail price of staple foods. Inputs travel the same roads as the harvest. Timing is also a design choice. CoAction Global’s newsletter describes a Private Sector Humanitarian Alliance that pools corporate contributions in advance so money is ready at the time of need, and it planned a first operational version this autumn; we did not check whether it has launched. Pre positioned money is the same logic a seasonal loan needs. The crop in this trial, cocoa, is one of the West African foods Our World in Data’s new trade tool follows to consumers worldwide.

Women farmers meet a harder test

The Food and Agriculture Organization’s April 2026 report estimates that 76% of working women in Sub Saharan Africa work in agrifood systems. A guest column in AllAfrica on 15 October cites World Bank research in Nigeria that found loan rejection of 56% for women owned businesses against 17% for male led firms, about 3.3 times higher by our arithmetic. NextBillion’s 2020 piece on women feeding Africa reports that closing the gender gap in inputs could raise yields by 20 to 30%, and that women receive less than 10% of extension services. It also describes TruTrade paying women farmers in Kenya and Uganda through mobile phones, which builds a digital profile as a by product.

Loan rejection in Nigeria

World Bank research as cited in AllAfrica, 15 October 2026

Women-owned businessesWomen-owned businesses: 56%56%Male-led businessesMale-led businesses: 17%17%Share of loan applications rejected. Our arithmetic: 56 divided by 17 is about 3.3

Two newsletters point at what to measure. The World Bank’s UFGE reports new Africa Gender Innovation Lab tools for measuring agency, covering goal setting, belief in one’s ability to shape outcomes and self efficacy in livelihoods and agriculture, using surveys from Benin, Côte d’Ivoire, Kenya, Malawi, Tanzania and Uganda; the measures link to earnings, food security and household decisions. Our reading is that these are willingness signals a lender might one day use beside repayment, and that is untested. UFGE also reports that the Dominican Republic’s banking regulator began requiring all financial institutions in May 2026 to report sex disaggregated MSME financing data, with 26 institutions holding about 97% of banking assets in the WE Finance Code. It is not an African case, but it shows lenders can be asked to count.

Power and cold rooms are part of the credit case

CoAction Global reports that Mission 300, led by the World Bank and African Development Bank, has connected more than 50 million people across 40 countries toward 300 million by 2030, and that its fellows now sit in 15 governments after 3,000 applications. Daily Maverick reports nearly $15 billion committed and about $4.5 billion in co financing. An electric connection is not yet farm income. The Global Energy Alliance and the World Bank announced a Productive Use of Energy Center of Excellence in May 2026 to link electrification with agriculture and small enterprise. Its vice president for Africa told Climate Home News that farmers on a mini grid still need access to the appliances, such as dryers, irrigation and cold storage, which is another barrier.

Mission 300 progress

Mission 300 partners, June 2026

Connected: more than 50 millionStill to connect: about 250 millionMore than 50 million connectedAbout 250 million still to connect0m100m200m300mMillions of people. Mission 300 partners as reported in June 2026;the goal is 300 million by 2030 and the 250 million is our arithmetic

That barrier is a credit product waiting to be designed. Africa Energy Portal argues that mills and cold rooms earn more per kilowatt hour, run in the day and form a bankable anchor load. It also reports that post harvest losses cost an estimated $4 billion a year, about 30% of grain and up to 50% of perishables. A GAIN working paper estimates 43.5% for vegetables and 55.9% for fruit in Sub Saharan Africa. The same paper and APHLIS note how little the literature addresses gender, though women do much of the drying, storing and processing. Our argument, untested, is that metered energy payments and cold chain throughput are further data trails, and that a loan for the machine can be assessed against them.

Losses after harvest in Sub Saharan Africa

Africa Energy Portal (grain, about 30%) and GAIN (vegetables, fruit); different sources and years

Grain (approx.)Grain (approx.): 30%30%VegetablesVegetables: 43.5%43.5%FruitFruit: 55.9%55.9%Share of production lost after harvest

Declarations need delivery systems

Africa has declared its way to this point. The Maputo Declaration of 2003 asked governments to put 10% of budgets into agriculture, and the Malabo Declaration followed in 2014. By 2023 no African Union member state was on track to meet Malabo’s 2025 targets, and the fourth Biennial Review exposed weak data collection and reporting. The Kampala Declaration, adopted on 11 January 2025 and in force since 1 January 2026, sets 2035 targets of 45% more agricultural output, halved post harvest losses, tripled intra African agricultural trade and at least $100 billion in investment, and repeats the 10% budget goal. The Malabo Montpellier Panel’s December 2025 playbook says Africa lacks scale and consistency in execution, and cites blended finance, revolving funds and results based subsidies in Morocco, Zambia and Seychelles that widened access to capital for women and young farmers.

From Maputo to the end of COP31

Dates from the sources cited

Jul 2003: Maputo: 10% of budgetsJul 2003Maputo: 10%of budgetsJun 2014: Malabo DeclarationJun 2014MalaboDeclaration2015: ILO R204 on formalisation2015ILO R204 onformalisationJan 2025: Kampala adoptedJan 2025KampalaadoptedJan 2026: Kampala in forceJan 2026Kampalain forceJun 2026: Mission 300: 50m connectedJun 2026Mission 300:50m connectedNov 2026: COP31 closes on 20 NovNov 2026COP31 closeson 20 NovSpacing is not to scale

The same lesson appears in climate policy. A June 2026 report by IDDRI, the DDP Initiative and the Wuppertal Institute, summarised in DDP Insights, found that nine countries, including Nigeria, Senegal and South Africa, reflected themes of the first Global Stocktake in their latest climate plans, including land use and ecosystem protection, but rarely cited it. The report argues for moving from “Stocktake to plans” to “Stocktake to implementation”, linking outcomes to planning systems and investment decisions. For farm credit, that means a declaration is only as good as the system that carries it to a field. GLF’s newsletter shows one small design, EUR 5,000 of trust based funding with mentoring for young restorers, and its report with partners says a funding shortage holds back youth led action. Whether trust based money works at farm scale is untested. The World Bank’s July classifications moved six of 218 economies to higher income groups, and the newsletter does not name them. Our inference is that as economies graduate, concessional money thins and domestic lenders carry more of the load.

Where plot level data fits

If lenders need records they can verify, the plot is the richest source and the least used. AgriKonnekt, per a Paris Peace Forum project summary, helps youth and women led cooperatives verify regenerative practices with offline AI and soil sensors and receive payments by mobile money. Those are two of Sodamola’s layers, data and incentives, tied to a cooperative’s identity. We have not seen the approach tested in lending, so that fit is our argument.

What to do next

  1. Match loan dates to the planting calendar, and publish the share of inputs delivered before planting.
  2. Score what the farm already produces, such as mobile money, produce sales and group savings, and read seasonal swings as normal.
  3. Let identity build through use, not only through documents.
  4. Record transactions under the person who earns, and report lending by sex, as the Dominican Republic now requires.
  5. Finance the appliance with the connection, so Mission 300 customers can buy dryers, pumps and cold storage.
  6. Use savings groups and cooperative records as the trust layer, and test on a small scale first.
  7. Report credit to farms by size and sex in the Kampala review, since the Malabo review failed partly on data.

What we can and cannot claim

StatementEvidence status
97.9% of agricultural employment in Sub Saharan Africa is informalILO data (2018) via an INCLUDE summary; old
Agri SME demand is $160 billion, with $54 billion metISF and CASA via AgriLinks; Sub Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia combined; about 2022
40% of adults in Sub Saharan Africa held mobile money in 2024Global Findex 2025 via World Bank and trade reports
Digital input credit raised spending 11% with no significant average effect on output or profitJ-PAL and VoxDev summaries; one lender, one region
On time loans did betterNon randomised comparison; authors cautious
Mission 300 has connected 50 million peoplePartner reports; the AfDB tracker uses a different measure
Credit is a system design problemPractitioner argument by Sodamola; not a trial
Plot data and energy payments could support creditOur argument; not tested
Connections will raise farm incomeUnknown; productive use is the aim, evidence pending

The farmer who needs fifty dollars at planting is not a bad borrower. She is a good one the system cannot see. The data say agriculture is the most informal work in Africa, the gap sits in the middle, and mobile money has already laid a trail. The Ghana trial says a loan that arrives late is not much of a loan, and the energy and gender evidence says the machine and the woman who works it belong in the same file. Declarations from Maputo to Kampala set the target. Credit systems that read informal data, at the time of need, are how a pledge turns into a planted field.

Sources & notes

SOURCES: ILO, More than 60 per cent of the world’s employed population are in the informal economy (2018); INCLUDE, Policy highlights on informal employment in Sub Saharan Africa; World Economic Forum, Informal economies don’t need fixing; AgriLinks, State of the Sector: Agri SME Finance (ISF Advisors and CASA); COLEAD, Why MSMEs in Sub Saharan Africa’s agricultural sector struggle to access finance; IBS Intelligence, FinTech opens new doors for Africa’s small farmers (2025); BusinessDay, Nigerian small businesses suffer $32.2bn finance gap (IFC); African Business, Closing Africa’s MSME finance gap (2018); World Bank, Global Findex 2025 press release; FXC Intelligence, Global Findex 2025 insights; Engineering News, Mobile phones help to boost formal savings; BusinessDay, Why millions in sub Saharan Africa don’t have mobile money accounts; NextBillion, Designing Credit Systems for Informal Economies (Sodamola, 30 June 2026); NextBillion, Women Feeding Africa (2020); FSD Tanzania, From Invisible to Investable (February 2026); BMZ Digital Global, AI levels the field: Kenyan farmers get smarter access to credit; McKinsey, New credit risk models for the unbanked; Sarfo, Musshoff, Weber and Danne, Farmers’ willingness to pay for digital credit, Madagascar (2021); J-PAL, Digital Credit to Support Farmers’ Input use and Productivity in Ghana; VoxDev, Can digital credit unlock investment in smallholder farms? (15 April 2026); Karlan, Lambon Quayefio, Manjeer and Udry, Access to Digital Credit for Smallholder Farmers (working paper); AllAfrica, How Reliable Energy Can Turn a Woman’s Harvest Into a Thriving Business (15 October 2026); Daily Maverick, Mission 300 flips the switch for 50 million Africans (18 June 2026); Climate Home News, Q&A on African electricity access and jobs (29 May 2026); Global Energy Alliance, Partnership to expand productive use of energy across Africa (May 2026); Africa Energy Portal, Energy Access for Productive Use (23 July 2026); GAIN, Gender equity and reduction of post harvest losses (Working Paper 20, 2021); APHLIS, The role of women in reducing postharvest loss; AgriFocus Africa, Policy playbook as the Kampala Declaration takes effect (19 December 2025); WOAH Africa, African Union adopts third CAADP roadmap; Africa.com, Reflecting on the Malabo Declaration; Down To Earth, African leaders adopt the Kampala Declaration; Paris Peace Forum, Democratising climate finance for smallholder farmers; CoAction Global newsletter, Mission 300 Fellowship and the Private Sector Humanitarian Alliance; GLF Youth newsletter, June 2026; DDP Insights, From Global Stocktake to National Action (IDDRI, DDP and Wuppertal Institute, June 2026); World Bank UFGE quarterly newsletter, June 2026; The OWID Brief, Our World in Data; World Bank Newsletter, 3 July 2026; NextBillion newsletter, featured jobs, business development and news.

Differences between sources: the agri SME gap is $106 billion for Sub Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia in the ISF and CASA estimate, $74 billion a year for Sub Saharan Africa in COLEAD, and $117 billion for smallholders in an unnamed study cited by IBS Intelligence; the informal share of 85.8% is labelled Africa by the ILO and Sub Saharan Africa by INCLUDE; Africans without electricity are nearly 600 million in the World Bank and CoAction Global material and more than 560 million in an IEA figure cited by AllAfrica; Mission 300 has connected more than 50 million people by its partners’ count, while the AfDB tracker reported by Climate Home News counted 34.6 million people due to be connected by projects underway in May; post harvest loss is about 30% of grain and up to 50% of perishables in Africa Energy Portal, up to 50% of crop production in APHLIS, and 43.5% for vegetables and 55.9% for fruit in GAIN; the Ghana trial reports 62% of applicants eligible in the working paper and 59% of the credit group receiving a loan in J-PAL; the typical Ghanaian farmer’s need is about 500 cedis in VoxDev while the loan ceiling was about 350 cedis.

Our own arithmetic: the 14.2% formal share; the $106 billion gap as $160 billion less $54 billion, with $54 billion about 34% of $160 billion; the 2021 formal saving rate of 23% as 35% less the reported 12 points; mobile money gains of 2.3 points a year from 2014 to 2021 and 4.3 a year from 2021 to 2024; loan rejection of 56% against 17% as about 3.3 times; and the 250 million people still to connect as 300 million less 50 million.