Close
Policy

Malawi’s subsidy cut shows what freed money should buy

(8 min read)

Governments across Africa spend heavily to put fertilizer and seed in farmers’ hands, and the evidence says the money does less than hoped. Meanwhile the World Bank’s Hooked on Subsidies report finds that emerging and developing economies spend about 6.9% of GDP on subsidies, more than on health and education combined, and that reform could free up to 1.9% of GDP in high subsidy countries. This article asks a practical question for African governments, cooperatives and agribusinesses: if input subsidies are trimmed or redesigned, what should the freed money buy so that farms, and not only bags, improve?

Read this first. We read in full the World Bank Governance update, the World Bank Publications notes on Nourish and Flourish and Industrial Policy for Development, the Latin America and Caribbean newsletter and the NextBillion issue on climate finance. We read the Jayne review, the World Bank’s subsidy and Bangladesh pages and the Malawi budget coverage as search extracts, not full documents, and we did not read the Malawi budget statement itself. Malawi’s figures come from press reports of it. Searches ran on 16 November 2026.

Five findings

  • Input subsidies work, but less than expected. A review of nearly 80 studies in seven African countries found higher yields for recipients, partly offset by crowding out of commercial fertilizer sales.
  • Malawi is reforming now. Its 2026/27 budget cuts the fertilizer subsidy to K111.45 billion from K241 billion.
  • Targeting decides who gains. In Bangladesh, a comparator outside Africa, the top 20% of landholders receive about half of fertilizer subsidy benefits.
  • Use is still low. Africa’s fertilizer use is about 18 kg a hectare against a target of 50, so the debate is about design, not abandonment.
  • The freed money has clear uses. Irrigation and water services, data, credit timed to harvests and processing capacity.

What the evidence says

Jayne, Mason, Burke and Ariga reviewed nearly 80 studies from Ghana, Nigeria, Kenya, Tanzania, Malawi, Zambia and Ethiopia in Food Policy in 2018. Subsidy programmes can quickly raise national food production, and recipients’ grain yields rise at least in the short term. Overall effects tend to be smaller than expected for two reasons: programmes partly crowd out commercial fertilizer demand, and maize responds less to fertilizer on smallholder plots than assumed. A 2017 lecture by Jayne put Malawi’s annual programme cost at US$152 million to US$275 million, 47% to 71% of the agricultural budget, and warned that a large share can crowd out other public investment.

The case for fertilizer itself is untouched. African Union summit documents say average use rose from 8 kg to about 18 kg a hectare between 2006 and 2022, against the Abuja target of 50 kg.

Fertilizer use against the Abuja target

Kilograms of nutrients per hectare, Africa average. African Union summit documents and press reports; the gap is our arithmetic

0204060Abuja target: 50 kg/ha8 kg/haabout 18 kg/ha20062022Gap in 2022: about 32 kg/ha

Malawi: a budget in motion

Malawi’s 2026/27 budget allocates K931.1 billion to agriculture, of which K111.45 billion is for the fertilizer input subsidy, down from K241 billion the year before, a cut of almost 54%. K40 billion goes to the National Irrigation Development Programme. The Farmers Union of Malawi has said the number of beneficiaries will fall, and the agriculture minister has said inputs will still be distributed but “in a very different way”, with farmer groups pooling funds under a Resource Mobilisation Initiative.

Malawi’s 2026/27 agricultural allocation

K931.1 billion in total; area in proportion to value. Press reports of the 2026/27 budget; remainder is our arithmetic

Rest of agriculture: K779.65bnRest of agricultural allocationK779.65bn, our arithmeticFertilizer subsidy: K111.45bnSubsidyK111.45bnIrrigation: K40bnIrrigationK40bn
Malawi’s fertilizer subsidy, year on year

Kwacha billion. Press reports of the 2026/27 budget; the cut is our arithmetic

01002002025/26: K241bnK241bnSubsidy, last yearCut: K129.55bn–K129.55bnCut, almost 54%2026/27: K111.45bnK111.45bnSubsidy, this year

The subsidy is now about 12% of the agricultural allocation, which is about 8.5% of the total K10.978 trillion budget. Budget definitions differ, so this is not strictly comparable with the older 47% to 71% estimate. Bangladesh, by contrast, spends nearly 80% of its agriculture ministry’s budget on fertilizer subsidies.

Fertilizer subsidy as a share of the agricultural budget

Per cent. Bangladesh: share of agriculture ministry budget, World Bank. Malawi: Jayne 2017 lecture; 2026/27 share is our arithmetic. Bases differ

0%25%50%75%100%Bangladesh, 2026Bangladesh, 2026: about 80%about 80%Malawi, earlier estimateMalawi, earlier estimate: 47% to 71%Malawi, earlier estimate: 47% to 71%47% to 71%Malawi, 2026/27Malawi, 2026/27: about 12%about 12%

Who receives the benefit

A June 2026 World Bank report on Bangladesh finds that because subsidies follow fertilizer purchased, farmers with more land receive more. The top 20% of landholders receive about half of the benefits and the bottom 40% about 15%, and only about 5% of farmers apply a balanced nutrient mix. Livestock, fisheries and horticulture produce three quarters of agricultural GDP but receive under 20% of spending, while rice takes 73% of allocations. The report recommends sequenced reform toward research, extension and market infrastructure, and eventually targeted, farmer linked support.

Bangladesh: who gets the fertilizer subsidy

Share of benefits by landholding group, a comparator outside Africa. World Bank, June 2026; middle group is our arithmetic

Top 20% of landholders: about 50%Middle 40%: about 35%Bottom 40%: about 15%Top 20% of landholdersabout 50%Middle 40%about 35%Bottom 40%about 15%80%of ministry budget
Bangladesh: spending against output

Per cent. World Bank, June 2026, as reported by Observer BD; “under 20%” is drawn at 20%

0%25%50%75%100%Livestock, fisheries, horticulture: share of agricultural GDP: 75%75%Livestock, fisheries, horticultureshare of agricultural GDPSame sub-sectors: share of spending: under 20%under 20%Same sub-sectorsshare of spendingRice: share of allocations: 73%73%Riceshare of allocations

African studies point the same way. Jayne’s review notes difficulty in targeting, crowding out of commercial sales, and in some programmes lower access for female headed households.

What the freed money should buy

The World Bank’s Nourish and Flourish report argues that feeding a projected 10 billion people by 2050 needs three shifts in agricultural water management: balance people, prosperity and planet; move incentives from hardware to services; and replace guesswork with data. It also asks how the transition will be financed, with a larger role for private investment. Malawi’s K40 billion for irrigation is one early example of money moving toward water.

Credit can follow the same logic. In Honduras, the bank BANHCAFE is expanding credit tailored to specific crops, regions and harvest cycles, in a country where over 80% of the workforce is informal. Further down the chain, the World Bank’s Latin America newsletter reports that women in Ecuador handle nearly 80% of seafood processing and almost half of marketing, a reminder that processing and trade are where many jobs sit.

Climate resilience needs capital as well. NextBillion reports that Africa needs about US$277 billion a year for its 2030 climate goals against flows of US$44 billion to US$50 billion, concentrated in a handful of companies and countries.

Africa’s climate finance gap

US$ billion a year. Bakshi and Singh in NextBillion; flows drawn at the upper figure

0100200300Yearly need, 2030 goals: US$277bnUS$277bnYearly need, 2030 goalsYearly flows: US$44bn to 50bnUS$44bn to 50bnYearly flows

Six actions

ActionEvidence
Inventory every farm subsidy before changing oneHooked on Subsidies: track, report and evaluate
Target by need, not purchase volumeBangladesh: top 20% receive about half
Sequence cuts with replacementsMalawi: irrigation and group purchasing alongside a smaller subsidy
Fund water and extension servicesNourish and Flourish; Malawi’s K40 billion
Time credit to the crop cycleBANHCAFE, Honduras
Measure fertilizer use and yields on actual plotsJayne: crowding out and weak yield response

A subsidy is a promise that a bag will become a harvest, and the evidence says that promise holds only when farmers can buy, apply and market what they grow. Malawi’s budget shows a government testing a smaller subsidy beside irrigation, Bangladesh shows how a large one can drift toward the best off, and the fertilizer figures show how far African use still has to travel. Cooperatives and agribusinesses that keep records of who received what, and how plots performed, will be best placed to help governments redesign support rather than simply cut it.

Sources & notes

SOURCES: World Bank Group Governance Global Department update (June 2026); World Bank Group Publications, Nourish and Flourish and Industrial Policy for Development (2026); World Bank LAC newsletter (June 2026); NextBillion newsletter, climate finance issue (June 2026); World Bank, Hooked on Subsidies: The Case for Reform; Jayne et al., Food Policy, 2018; Jayne, input subsidy programs in Africa (2017 lecture); The Nation, Malawi cuts input subsidy spending; The Nation, FUM faults budget; The Nation, AIP reforms; AllAfrica, Malawi passes 2026/27 budget; Financial Afrik, Malawi budget; World Bank, Smarter agricultural public spending in Bangladesh; Observer BD, 80pc of agri budget goes to fertiliser subsidies; African Union, Africa Fertilizer and Soil Health Action Plan; The Star, African nations vow to triple fertiliser production; AgriKonnekt.

Differences between sources: Malawi’s programme is called FISP in press reports and AIP in government statements after its renaming; the earlier 47% to 71% share comes from a 2017 lecture whose years are not stated and may use a different budget definition; Bangladesh’s 80% is of the agriculture ministry’s budget, not the whole agricultural sector.

Our own arithmetic: the K129.55 billion cut; the 12% subsidy share; the 8.5% share of Malawi’s total budget; the 35% middle group in the Bangladesh benefit chart; the K779.65 billion remainder of Malawi’s agricultural allocation.