Close
Research

Water, cash and care keep cooperatives going when seasons fail

(12 min read)

A year ago this month, three World Bank publications landed within weeks of each other: a first global water monitoring report, a revised damage count for Hurricane Melissa, and a social protection report that put a number on who is left out. Read next to WHO and UNICEF’s sanitation data, they describe one gap from three angles. A cooperative of smallholders needs water to grow, cash to survive the bad season, and care and basic services to free its members’ time. When any of the three fails, no seed or fertiliser can make up for it. This article reads those releases for what they mean for the cooperatives Kilimora serves through AgriKonnekt.

A correction first. Our companion piece, “Who pays when the rain fails?”, used the Jamaican prime minister’s early range of US$6 to 7 billion for Hurricane Melissa’s damage. The joint World Bank and IDB estimate that followed on 19 November 2025 is US$8.8 billion, so the insurance payouts were about 2.7% of damage, not 3.5%. That is itself a finding, and we come back to it.

Four numbers from one November

World Bank and WHO/UNICEF figures published between August and November 2025

324B m³freshwater lost each year,enough for 280M people3.4Bpeople without safelymanaged sanitation1.6Bpeople in low and middle incomecountries with no social protectionUS$8.8BMelissa damage, Jamaica:41% of GDP

Eight findings

  • The world is drying. It loses 324 billion cubic metres of fresh water a year, enough for 280 million people.
  • Farming choices are part of the cause. 37 drying countries have moved to more water intensive crops; 22 of them are arid or semi arid.
  • Drought is a jobs shock. In Sub Saharan Africa it leaves 600,000 to 900,000 people out of work each year, women first.
  • First damage counts run low. Melissa’s final figure is 26 to 47% above the first one, and payouts covered 2.7% of it.
  • The basics are unfinished. 3.4 billion people lack safely managed sanitation and 2.1 billion lack safe drinking water.
  • Social protection is huge and incomplete. 4.7 billion people are covered, 1.6 billion have nothing, and women get 81 cents for each dollar men receive.
  • Design decides outcomes. Cash to women in Nigeria lifted business ownership 20 points; a Nepali old age allowance left older women hungrier relative to men.
  • Kenya has a working template. The Hunger Safety Net pays before hunger peaks, triggered by satellite data.

Water: the number behind the number

The Global Water Monitoring Report, written by Fan Zhang and colleagues and built on two decades of satellite data, says the planet is losing fresh water at a rate that could meet the needs of 280 million people a year. The causes it names are human: poor pricing, weak coordination, deforestation, wetland loss and excessive irrigation. Global water use is up 25% since 2000, and a third of that rise is in places already drying out.

The world dries faster than trade can compensate

Billion cubic metres of fresh water a year. World Bank, Global Water Monitoring Report, first edition

Freshwater lost each year324324Saved each year by virtualwater trade, since 2010475475

Two findings matter most for farmers. First, the shift in crops: among drying countries, 37 moved to more water intensive agriculture, including 22 in arid and semi arid regions, and more than two thirds of inefficient irrigation in drying areas is linked to rice, wheat, cotton, maize or sugar cane. Second, the human cost: drought leaves 600,000 to 900,000 people in Sub Saharan Africa jobless every year.

Thirsty crops in thirsty places

37 drying countries have shifted to more water intensive agriculture

Arid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridArid or semi-aridOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying countryOther drying country22 arid or semi-arid15 othersEach dot is one drying country that moved to more water-intensive crops
What drought does to jobs in Sub Saharan Africa

People left without work by drought each year

600,000 to 900,0000500,0001 million600,000 to 900,000 a year

Two caveats keep us honest. The irrigation finding concerns irrigated land, and most smallholders in Kilimora’s counties farm rain fed plots, so it should not be read as a verdict on their maize. And the report’s county level view is a global product: we have not yet pulled Kenya’s county results, which is the obvious next step. For Kilimora: the report’s method is the same one AgriKonnekt uses at plot scale, satellite data checked against the ground. The gap it cannot fill is the farm itself, and that is where measured soil moisture and tree cover on cooperative plots, reported openly, would add to the national picture.

Melissa: a lesson in being measured late

When Hurricane Melissa made landfall on 28 October 2025, the first public loss range was US$6 to 7 billion. Three weeks later, a rapid damage assessment by the World Bank and the IDB put physical damage at US$8.8 billion, 41% of 2024 GDP and the costliest hurricane in Jamaica’s history. Housing took 41% of the damage and infrastructure 33%. The catastrophe bond and CCRIF paid US$241.9 million quickly; a US$6.7 billion package from five lenders, mostly financing and credit lines, followed.

Melissa: the first estimate was too low

Jamaica, US$ billion. Preliminary government range against the joint World Bank and IDB damage assessment, and what was paid or promised

Preliminary estimate (top)6 to 76 to 7Joint damage assessment (GRADE)8.88.8Recovery financing package(over three years, up to)6.76.7Bond and CCRIF payouts0.240.24
Where the damage fell

Share of Melissa’s US$8.8B physical damage by sector. Agriculture is 5% of physical damage, but its income losses last longer

Housing 41%Infrastructure 33%Non-residential 21%Farms 5%

The lesson for smallholders is about evidence. Quick money is valuable, but damage is only known late, and agriculture’s share looks small (5%) because income losses do not show up as broken buildings. Dated plot records taken before and after a shock are the cheapest way to make farm losses visible. For Kilimora: that is the case for keeping a baseline for every member plot, as we argued in Closing the verification gap.

Sanitation, water and the time women lose

WHO and UNICEF’s 2025 update counts 3.4 billion people without safely managed sanitation, 2.1 billion without safely managed drinking water and 1.7 billion without basic hygiene at home. Rural safely managed water coverage rose from 50% to 60% between 2015 and 2024, while urban coverage stagnated. In most countries women and girls collect the water, and many in Sub Saharan Africa spend more than 30 minutes a day on it (UNRIC).

The unfinished basics

People still lacking each service in 2024, billions. WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme

Safely managed sanitation3.4B3.4BSafely managed drinking water2.1B2.1BBasic hygiene at home1.7B1.7BOpen defecation354M354M

This is an agricultural issue, not only a health one. Time spent on water and care is time not spent on the plot, and FAO’s evidence that women headed households lose 8% more income to heat suggests the burden stacks. For Kilimora: AgriKonnekt’s USSD lessons and mobile payments are designed to need little time and no data plan, but we should measure the hours they save or cost, and not assume them.

Cash: a shield with holes, and what makes it work

The World Bank’s State of Social Protection Report 2025 is blunt. Coverage has reached a record 4.7 billion people, yet about 2 billion remain uncovered or inadequately covered, including over a billion in Africa and South Asia. Only one in four people in low income countries benefit, and women receive 81 cents for each dollar men receive across 27 countries. At today’s pace, universal coverage for the poorest is about two decades away.

A record shield, still full of holes

People in low and middle income countries, billions. World Bank, State of Social Protection Report 2025

Covered over ten years (record)4.7B4.7BUncovered or inadequately covered2.0B2.0BNo coverage at all1.6B1.6BCovered, but benefits too small0.4B0.4B
Women receive less of the same benefit

Average social protection benefit, cents per US$1 received by men, sample of 27 countries

Men100100Women8181

The research summarised in the same month’s WEESA digest shows why design matters. A meta analysis of 106 studies covering over 200,000 women in 42 countries found the strongest gains from unconditional cash, asset transfers and social care services, and weaker or inconsistent effects from conditional cash and in kind programmes. In Northern Nigeria, an unconditional transfer to ultra poor households raised women’s enterprise ownership by 20 points a year after payments ended, and by 13 points among neighbours who got nothing (World Bank working paper). In Nepal, a universal old age allowance left eligible older women 8.8 points likelier to eat fewer meals than men and 5.3 points likelier to go hungry, because resources were shared unevenly inside the household.

Same idea, different design, opposite results

Percentage point changes. Nigeria: women’s business ownership one year after transfers ended. Nepal: eligible older women compared with men, after a universal old age allowance

Nigeria: women who got cash+20+20Nigeria: neighbours with no cash+13+13Nepal: older women eat fewer meals+8.8+8.8Nepal: older women go hungry+5.3+5.3

Kenya has a home grown version of the good design. The Hunger Safety Net Programme pays about 100,000 of the poorest households in Marsabit, Mandera, Turkana and Wajir regularly, and keeps a further 470,000 households registered for emergency payments. A satellite vegetation index sets the trigger: at “severe” drought an extra 25% of households are paid, at “extreme” up to 75%. The first scale up in April 2015 reached over 90,000 households (CALP).

Kenya already pays before the hunger arrives

Hunger Safety Net Programme, four northern counties, households in thousands

Regular cash, poorest householdsabout 100about 100Paid in the first droughtscale-up, April 201590+90+Pre-registered for emergencypayments470470

For Kilimora: two links. AgriKonnekt pays members straight to mobile accounts, so the 24 hour promise matches what the evidence says works for women: money in their own hands. And HSNP shows the model of a satellite trigger that pays before the shock peaks. Kilimora is not a safety net operator; the practical step is to make cooperative plot data something a public scheme like this one could draw on.

Jobs, skills and the young

The labour market is the quiet part of all this. The World Bank’s Spring Meetings material counts 1.2 billion young people reaching working age in emerging economies over the next decade against about 420 million jobs expected, and its November newsletter says nearly 23% of young Africans are not in education, employment or training.

The jobs arithmetic

Young people reaching working age in emerging economies over the next decade, against jobs expected, millions

Young people reaching working age1,2001,200Jobs expected to be created420420

Adaptation and verification create jobs: field educators, data collectors, cooperative managers, nursery and tree care workers. Kilimora’s target of 5,000 direct roles, with women in more than 60%, should be reported the same way as the cash: by gender, by county and by how long the jobs last.

What we can and cannot claim

LifelineWhat AgriKonnekt is designed to doEvidence status
WaterBetter soil, tree cover and plot monitoringNo measured water saving published; extra soil carbon adds little available water in many soils
CashMobile payments within 24 hours of funder releaseDesign claim; no payments by gender report yet
Care and timeUSSD lessons that need no data planHours saved or spent not measured
Jobs5,000 direct roles targeted, women in over 60%Target, not result
VerificationAbout 70% lower cost on a 1,500 farmer pilotPilot estimate; not independently audited

What we would ask for

  1. Publish Kenya’s county level results from the Global Water Monitoring Report and match them to cooperative plots.
  2. Take a plot baseline before every season so farm losses are visible after a shock, not only buildings.
  3. Report cash payments by gender and household role, benchmarked to the 81 cent gap.
  4. Pay women directly, in unconditional or lightly conditioned form, where evidence supports it.
  5. Measure hours spent on water, care and training, before and after.
  6. Link cooperative records to public triggers like HSNP’s, with the member’s consent.
  7. Fund sanitation and water at village level alongside agriculture, not after it.
  8. Track the jobs created and how long they last.
Sources & notes

SOURCES: World Bank; WHO/UNICEF JMP; State of Social Protection 2025; World Bank and IDB; World Bank, Global Water Monitoring Report press release and Continental Drying report, 4 November 2025; Hurricane Melissa damage, 19 November 2025; IDB, joint estimate; sector split; LatinNews, preliminary range; Jamaica Gleaner, financing package; Insurance Business, payouts; WHO/UNICEF JMP, fast facts, UNRIC, data; World Bank, State of Social Protection 2025, blog; Down To Earth, coverage summary; Papineni and colleagues, Cash Is Queen and blog; Kenya Hunger Safety Net, EU case study, CALP review, OPM, DAI; FAO, The Unjust Climate; World Bank Spring Meetings text; Kilimora, AgriKonnekt, Closing the verification gap. The World Bank WEESA digest (November 2025) and World Bank newsletter of 21 November 2025 are email newsletters without links; findings from them, including the meta analysis of 106 studies and the Nepal result, are as summarised there and not checked against the primary papers. Notes carried over from the graphics: virtual water is the water embedded in traded crops and goods; the drought jobs report says women, older people, landless farmers and low skilled workers are hit hardest; the World Bank aims to reach 500 million more people with social protection by 2030, half of them women; the Nigeria study reports a partial income multiplier of at least 0.32 and little change in attitudes. Our own arithmetic: payout share, 26 to 47% understatement. Kilimora statements about its systems are the company’s own.