Close
Climate Finance

Climate pledges matter less than their timing and route

(10 min read)

The COP31 talks in Antalya opened with a paradox about money. On the Guardian’s reading of analysis by two thinktanks, rich countries are broadly on track to deliver the $300 billion a year of climate finance they promised by 2035, yet many have not said how they will do it. For an African cooperative planning next season’s seed, soil and irrigation, that silence matters as much as the total. This article follows the problem from the negotiating room to the farm: what the Guardian found, how falling aid and thin adaptation finance compound it, and how one Kenyan programme shows what predictable, locally governed money looks like.

Read this first. We read the Guardian report in full. The East African article on Africa’s electricity, waste and resilience gaps is paywalled, and as before we read only its headline and use it for framing. We did not read the NRDC and E3G or Carbon Brief analyses the Guardian cites. Other figures come from UNEP, the OECD and Kenya’s Treasury. The summit continues to 20 November, so nothing here is a final outcome.

Six findings

  • The total may be fine. Developed countries should provide about $229 billion a year by 2030, with development banks supplying about $185 billion.
  • The detail is missing. France, Germany and Australia are among major countries yet to state new goals.
  • Aid to Africa is falling. Bilateral aid to sub Saharan Africa fell 26.3% in 2025 and is projected to fall another 11.6% in 2026.
  • Adaptation is the thinnest slice. International public flows were $26 billion in 2023 against a modelled need of $310 billion by 2035.
  • Kenya shows an alternative. Its county climate programme has reached 1,137 of 1,450 wards through performance tested grants.
  • Readiness decides who gets paid. Money follows places that can show plans, governance and results.

On track in total, silent in the detail

The 2024 Baku agreement commits rich countries to $300 billion a year by 2035, alongside about $1 trillion from other sources, the Guardian reports. According to analysis by NRDC and E3G, the developed world should reach about $229 billion a year by 2030, with multilateral development banks supplying about $185 billion. If the EU keeps up its current $36 billion a year and the UK, Canada and some smaller donors deliver what they have pledged, a gap of about $7 billion would remain. Joe Thwaites of NRDC says most countries look in good shape but are not being public about it, which leaves developing countries unable to plan and makes private investors harder to attract.

Who carries the 2030 delivery

Billions of US dollars a year, 2030. NRDC and E3G analysis as reported by the Guardian. The $44bn remainder and the 81% share are our arithmetic

M: 81%O: 19%$229bnexpected by 2030Multilateral development banks: about $185bn (81%)Governments and other sources: about $44bn (our arithmetic)
The path to $300 billion

Billions of US dollars a year. NRDC and E3G analysis (2030) and the Baku goal (2035), as reported by the Guardian

050100150200250300350Expected|by 2030: $229bn$229bnExpectedby 2030Goal|by 2035: $300bn$300bnGoalby 2035

The silence is not uniform. Carbon Brief’s analysis, cited by the Guardian, found that if governments set no new finance after current targets expire, bilateral flows to the developing world would face 70% cuts, though Thwaites calls that very unlikely. France’s aid agency says it targets €6 billion a year for climate in 2025 to 2027. Japan says it has no new pledges planned but remains committed. The Guardian also reports that the World Bank retired its climate finance target this summer and that the UK cut its climate finance earlier this year. Because development banks carry most of the 2030 total, on these numbers their decisions matter more than any single donor’s.

The aid farms depend on is shrinking

Climate finance sits on top of ordinary aid, and that base is eroding. The OECD says net aid fell 23.3% in 2025, the largest drop on record, after an 8.5% fall in 2024, and projects a further 6.9% drop in 2026. Bilateral aid to sub Saharan Africa fell 26.3% in 2025 and is projected to decline 11.6% in 2026. The OECD also projects food aid to fall 44.5% between 2024 and 2026. An earlier OECD release put the 2025 fall at 23.1%, so the figure shifts slightly with revisions.

What is happening to aid

Real change in official development assistance, per cent. OECD, preliminary 2025 data and June 2026 projections, via TWN and OECD. Projections may change

Total aid, 2025Total aid, 2025: -23.3%−23.3%Bilateral aid to sub-Saharan Africa, 2025Bilateral aid to sub-Saharan Africa, 2025: -26.3%−26.3%Total aid, 2026 (projected)Total aid, 2026 (projected): -6.9%−6.9%Bilateral aid to sub-Saharan Africa, 2026 (projected)Bilateral aid to sub-Saharan Africa, 2026 (projected): -11.6%−11.6%Food aid, 2024 to 2026 (projected)Food aid, 2024 to 2026 (projected): -44.5%−44.5%Real change in official development assistance

For African farmers the exposure is direct wherever food security and farm programmes are aid funded, and the OECD’s projected 44.5% fall in food aid shows which way budgets are heading. We could not find a breakdown of aid to African agriculture alone, so we do not estimate that share.

Adaptation is the thinnest slice

UNEP’s Adaptation Gap Report 2025 puts developing countries’ adaptation needs at $310 billion a year by 2035 on modelled costs, or up to $365 billion by another method. International public adaptation finance was $26 billion in 2023, down from $28 billion a year earlier. The Glasgow goal of roughly doubling it to about $40 billion by 2025 will not be met on current trends, UNEP says. The $300 billion goal covers both mitigation and adaptation, so adaptation gets less of it. Debt made up around 59% of flows, which UNEP warns increases indebtedness, and private adaptation finance is only about $5 billion a year, with potential to reach about $50 billion given targeted policy and blended finance.

Adaptation money against adaptation need

Billions of US dollars a year. UNEP Adaptation Gap Report 2025. The need figure is a modelled estimate for 2035 in 2023 prices

050100150200250300350Flows|2022: $28bn$28bnFlows2022Flows|2023: $26bn$26bnFlows2023Glasgow doubling|target, 2025: $40bn$40bnGlasgow doublingtarget, 2025Modelled need|by 2035: $310bn$310bnModelled needby 2035

Adaptation is where farmers feel the effects first: drought tolerant seed, water harvesting, early warning and crop insurance are adaptation spending. UNEP notes that most countries now have adaptation plans, and over 1,600 implemented actions were reported, mostly in biodiversity, agriculture, water and infrastructure. The gap, then, is in funds rather than plans.

What predictable money looks like: Kenya’s county grants

Kenya’s Financing Locally Led Climate Action programme, or FLLoCA, is one working answer. Running from 2022 to 2027 with $294 million from the World Bank, Denmark, Sweden and Germany, it is implemented by the National Treasury with all 47 counties. Counties qualify for grants by meeting performance conditions, including a county climate change fund, a climate unit and participatory ward level risk assessments. According to the Standard, all 47 counties have passed climate fund laws that require at least 1.5% of development budgets for climate resilience, so some funding continues beyond the programme. By April 2026 the programme had backed more than 2,200 locally identified projects in areas including water, climate smart agriculture and landscape restoration, and the World Bank added $30 million. Disbursements reached $108.75 million against an initial projection of $85 million.

How far the county model has reached

Wards covered by FLLoCA, 2024/25 grant round. Kenya Treasury figures as reported by The Standard and Eastleigh Voice. The remainder is our arithmetic

R: 78.4%N: 21.6%78.4%of 1,450 wards1,137 wards reached (78.4%)313 wards still to reach (our arithmetic)
The chain behind a county grant

Our summary of FLLoCA’s structure from Treasury and press descriptions

PledgesClimate financegoalsPartnersWorld Bank, Danida,Sida, KfWTreasuryNational programmeunitCountiesPerformance-testedgrantsWardsLocal resilienceprojects

Two cautions apply. The donors behind FLLoCA are the same ones whose budgets are under pressure, so its continuation is not assured. Also, the project count and hectares restored (27,640 in one account) are government reported and we have not audited them.

Being ready when the plans arrive

Predictability does not only come from donors. Cooperatives and county planners can make themselves easier to fund by holding records, plans and results that a financier can check. Blended finance, which UNEP says could lift private adaptation money tenfold, relies on exactly that evidence. AgriKonnekt is built to check farm plots with sensors and satellites so cooperatives can show results to funders, according to the AgriKonnekt page. We have not seen it used with county grants, so any link to FLLoCA style funding is our proposal.

What to do next

  1. Cooperatives should ask their county climate unit which ward level priorities are funded this year and how to submit projects.
  2. Farmer organisations should keep a short readiness file: member records, plot data, a costed plan and past results.
  3. County governments should keep the 1.5% climate allocation protected in budget cycles, so local funding survives donor shifts.
  4. Donors should publish multi year climate finance plans, as the Guardian’s reporting shows many have not.
  5. Development banks should report how much of their climate lending reaches agriculture and small scale producers.
  6. Regulators should favour grants and concessional finance for adaptation, as UNEP advises, over loans that add to debt.

What we can and cannot claim

StatementEvidence status
About $229 billion a year expected by 2030, with $185 billion from development banksNRDC and E3G analysis as reported by the Guardian; analysis not read
Many donors have not set post-2027 plansGuardian reporting; some governments gave statements
Net aid fell 23.3% in 2025, with a further 6.9% fall projectedOECD; 2025 data revised from 23.1%; projections may change
Adaptation flows of $26 billion against a need of $310 billionUNEP Adaptation Gap Report 2025; needs are modelled
FLLoCA reached 1,137 of 1,450 wardsTreasury data as reported by the press; not audited
East African article contentHeadline only; paywalled
Verified plot data could support county or blended financeOur argument; not tested

The lesson from Antalya is that the size of a climate pledge matters less to a farmer than its timing, its form and its route. Totals may be on track, but aid to Africa is falling, adaptation money is a fraction of need, and many donors have gone quiet about what comes after current budgets. Kenya’s county grants show what a steadier route looks like: money tied to performance, held by local institutions and backed by a budget line that outlasts any single donor. Cooperatives that prepare records, plans and verified results now will be first in line when the plans do arrive.

Sources & notes

SOURCES: Fiona Harvey, Developing countries in limbo as rich nations delay new climate finance plans, The Guardian (11 November 2026); The East African, COP31: Africa presses for climate finance to close its electricity, waste and resilience gaps (11 November 2026, headline only); UNEP, Adaptation Gap Report 2025; Stockholm Environment Institute on the report; Mail and Guardian on adaptation finance; OECD, ODA projections for 2026; Third World Network on the OECD report; ONE on the preliminary 2025 aid data; Kenya Treasury, FLLoCA programme; The Standard on additional World Bank funding; The Standard on county grants; Eastleigh Voice on county grants; AgriKonnekt.

Differences between sources: aid fell 23.1% (April preliminary) or 23.3% (June brief) in 2025; the debt share of adaptation flows is 58% to 59%; UNEP’s need is $310 billion to $365 billion depending on method.

Our own arithmetic: the $44 billion non bank remainder and 81% bank share; the 313 uncovered wards.

Not read: the NRDC, E3G and Carbon Brief analyses, the full East African article, and FLLoCA grant manuals. Government project counts are as reported.