A cooperative that sells ten tonnes of maize, pays its members by mobile money and keeps its delivery log on a phone has produced something a bank can use: a record. Whether that record is ever counted depends on three things the February and March 2026 reading lists touched in different ways. NextBillion carried a debate on whether Africa should electrify households or businesses first. It also carried MicroSave’s account of women entrepreneurs who operate on trust and are invisible to formal credit. The Hinrich Foundation’s mailings followed the fast changing rules on digital trade and cross border data. This article tests those ideas against African evidence published before 14 November 2026 and asks what they mean for a farmer cooperative.
Read this first. We read the NextBillion articles by Alba Topulli and Todd Moss, by Nabilla Prita Fiandini and Monica Christy, and by Taiwo Hassan Odugbemi, plus the MicroSave summaries and the four newsletters. We did not read the Hinrich pieces on digital trade rules and data governance, so those are taken from their descriptions. The MicroSave study is from Indonesia, not Africa, and is used as a lens only. Research stops at 14 November 2026.
Five findings
- Power for production is a live debate. Topulli and Moss argue against choosing between household and business electricity, while Odugbemi replies that the trade offs are real.
- Unreliable grids cost firms. Odugbemi cites World Bank Enterprise Surveys showing self generated power often costs almost four times grid electricity.
- Africa has a trust data base. About 40% of adults in sub Saharan Africa held a mobile money account in 2024, up from 27% in 2021.
- Women are not catching up evenly. GSMA finds women in low and middle income countries were 36% less likely than men to own a mobile money account in 2024, against 30% in 2021.
- Data rules are spreading. The Malabo Convention entered into force on 8 June 2023, and national data protection laws now number in the dozens.
Power for production, not only for light
Topulli and Moss, writing on 18 February 2026, say progress has stalled over a false choice between solar home systems for households and cheaper, more reliable power for businesses. They want both, built around four interlocking pillars, the first being that initial household access is non negotiable. They place the debate against more than half a billion Africans still without electricity and Mission 300, which aims to connect 300 million people by 2030. A month later Odugbemi answered that the trade offs are real, that connected firms still suffer outages and voltage swings, and that electricity for production differs from electricity for consumption. He notes that South Africa’s 2023 load shedding cut growth by an estimated 1.5 percentage points.
Index, grid electricity = 100. Self generated power “often almost four times” grid cost, per Odugbemi citing World Bank Enterprise Surveys. The multiple is approximate
For agriculture the point is concrete. A mill, a dryer or a cold room is a production load, and it fails when the grid does. The World Bank’s 2024 utilities analysis, cited by the Energy for Growth Hub, found fewer than a quarter of sub Saharan utilities recover their costs, which helps explain why reliability lags. Pairing household access with dependable business grade supply at the points where produce is processed is the practical reading of both sides.
Trust is data: what Indonesia’s sellers show
MicroSave’s study of 458 social commerce sellers across seven Indonesian provinces, 70% of them women, found that only 15% had accessed formal credit and only 18% held a business identification number. The authors argue the issue is a mismatch between document based banking and trust based informal business, and that sellers’ social commerce activity can feed innovative credit scoring if data is shared ethically. African farm traders and women aggregators work in much the same way, selling on reputation through WhatsApp groups and village markets.
MicroSave Consulting, study of 458 sellers in seven provinces (Indonesia). Shown as a comparison, not African data
Africa already has the equivalent. The World Bank’s Global Findex 2025 puts sub Saharan account ownership at 58% of adults in 2024, up from 49% in 2021, with mobile money at 40% and formal saving at 35%. Those payment records are the trust data the MicroSave study describes. The gap is who benefits: GSMA’s analysis of the same survey shows the mobile money gender gap in low and middle income countries widened between 2021 and 2024, even though it narrowed in about two thirds of the 29 sub Saharan markets surveyed, and Findex notes only about half of mobile money users in the region protect their phones with passwords.
Percent of adults, 2021 and 2024. World Bank Global Findex 2025, as reported by Creamer Media and BusinessDay. The 2021 savings figure is derived from the reported 12 point rise to 35%
Rules for sharing the record
The Hinrich Foundation’s mailings describe a push toward more coherent digital trade rules in the Indo Pacific and Europe, and argue that the free and trusted flow of data across borders is central to technology leadership. Africa’s own frame is the African Union’s Malabo Convention, which took nine years to reach the 15 ratifications it needed and entered into force on 8 June 2023, alongside the AU Data Policy Framework of 2022. Counts of national data protection laws vary by source and date, from 33 in 2023 to 38 in 2024 and 44 in 2025, and enforcement lags the statute book in many places.
Counts differ by source and date and are not one series. EJIL Talk (2023), Okolo (2024), Digital Policy Alert as reported by Algeria Tech (2025)
For a cooperative the rule that matters is consent. MicroSave’s case for using transaction data to score credit depends on ethical data sharing, and the same applies to member delivery logs and payment histories. AgriKonnekt, which links farming cooperatives to mitigation and adaptation finance, relies on exactly this kind of member controlled record.
| Claim | Basis |
|---|---|
| Self generated power almost four times grid cost | Odugbemi citing World Bank Enterprise Surveys; approximate |
| Only 15% of sellers accessed formal credit | MicroSave study in Indonesia; not African data |
| Mobile money at 40% of adults in sub Saharan Africa | Global Findex 2025 |
| Mobile money gender gap 36% in 2024 | GSMA analysis of Findex; low and middle income countries overall |
| Malabo Convention in force since 8 June 2023 | African Union treaty record via legal commentary |
A record only counts when three things line up: power that stays on where produce is processed, a payment trail that a lender can read, and rules that let a farmer share that trail on her own terms. Africa has made visible progress on each, with mobile money reaching four in ten adults, a continental data convention in force, and a sharper debate about electricity for production. The weaker link is the gap between women and men in the very tools that generate the record, so the cooperatives and programmes that close it, and that keep records the farmer controls, will be the ones lenders and buyers can trust when the next season’s finance is decided.
Sources & notes
SOURCES: NextBillion, The False Choice in African Energy Access (18 February 2026); Energy for Growth Hub, The False Choice in African Energy Access; NextBillion, The Trade offs in African Energy Access are Real (16 March 2026); Energy for Growth Hub, New Funding for Energy Access Creates an Opportunity; NextBillion, Leveraging the Currency of Trust (12 February 2026); MicroSave, Empowering trust based MSMEs; MicroSave, Social Commerce Initiatives report; Creamer Media on Global Findex 2025; BusinessDay on Global Findex 2025 and mobile money; GSMA, Progress in closing the mobile money gender gap has stalled; EJIL Talk, The Malabo Convention enters into force; Okolo, Operationalizing Comprehensive Data Governance in Africa; Algeria Tech, African data protection laws and Malabo ratifications; AgriKonnekt.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN SOURCES: counts of African data protection laws are 33, 38 and 44 depending on date and method; Malabo ratifications are 15 at entry into force and 16 by early 2026; the GSMA gender gap is a low and middle income aggregate, not a sub Saharan figure; the Findex 2021 savings share is derived from the reported rise.
OUR OWN ARITHMETIC: percentage point rises from 2021 to 2024 of 9 for accounts, 13 for mobile money and 12 for formal saving; 2021 formal saving of 23% is 35% minus 12 points; the index of 400 against 100 is the “almost four times” cost multiple rounded.