Close
Climate Finance

Proof for smallholders is a public good that funders underpay

(12 min read)

Sub Saharan Africa will add more than 20 million working age people every year until 2050, and the industries that could employ them are not yet drawing in the capital they need. For a cooperative in Murang’a or Kakamega the problem looks smaller and more practical: the climate work is already being done, but funders want proof, and proof costs money. This article reads a pile of development dispatches from November 2025, two NextBillion newsletters, a Hinrich Foundation digest and a World Bank Live notice, beside what we publish about our own work on AgriKonnekt, and it asks three things: which claims matter to smallholder cooperatives, where the money stalls, and what we should do about it.

Eight findings

  • The jobs gap is larger than any one programme. More than 20 million new working age people a year means at least 500 million over 25 years. Our 2030 target of 5,000 direct roles is 0.025% of a single year’s increase.
  • Exit driven funding passes over public good work. Emre Eren Korkmaz of Oxford argues public innovation agencies are drifting toward venture capital logic. Shared verification infrastructure is the kind of work that logic under funds.
  • Capital is lumpy. One US$150 million award to Zipline is 30,000 times the top case competition prize in the same newsletters (US$5,000).
  • Diversified funding reaches the hardest places. Soluz Honduras shows it for off grid solar. Our plan caps any single revenue stream at 45% by 2030.
  • Projects fail for knowable reasons. The Global Plan of Action (GPA) and Innovation Norway have catalogued 25 for humanitarian energy. Our energy track should borrow the method.
  • Our own numbers need reconciling. The pilot implies 16 t of carbon potential per farmer. The 2030 plan implies 3.6 t, a fall of 77.5%.
  • Lenders learn from applicants. 60 Decibels spoke to more than 400 Brazilian loan applicants. Nobody has yet asked our 1,500 farmers the same questions at scale.
  • Concentration is a risk, and so is who is in the room. Malaysia’s tariff exposure and the COP30 lobbying count make the same point from opposite ends.

What we read, and how far to trust it

The material is a set of newsletters, not the underlying reports. The Hinrich Foundation issue summarised work by Deborah Elms on trade policy, Angela Tritto on ASEAN semiconductors, Jia Hui Tee and the Harvard Growth Lab on Malaysian exports, and a discussion guide on China’s export led growth by Dinny McMahon and David Zhang. The NextBillion issues covered job creation, public innovation agencies, off grid solar finance and Brazilian small business lending. The World Bank Live notice gave only a title, a date and a format: “Forests for the Future”, 18 November 2025, online. We have not read the full papers, so we summarise what the newsletters say and no more. All of it is a year old, the deadlines it mentions have passed, and we have not checked what has changed since. Kilimora figures are as published on our own pages and have not been independently verified.

The jobs arithmetic

Loïc De Cannière of Incofin Investment Management argues, in the NextBillion summary, that employment is not keeping pace with the growth in working age people, and that agri food is the sector with the most job creating potential. The scale is easy to underestimate.

The working age wave, cumulative

Added working age people in Sub Saharan Africa since 2025, at the stated minimum of 20 million a year. Our arithmetic from the NextBillion summary

0250M500M2030: 100 million100M20302035: 200 million200M20352040: 300 million300M20402045: 400 million400M20452050: 500 million500M2050Kilimora 2030 target:5,000 direct roles, 0.025%of one year’s increase

The honest reading is that no single organisation closes this gap, and that our own target is a pattern more than a dent. AgriKonnekt’s cooperative cascade, in which each new network trains its own farmer educators, creates roles for farmer educators, data collectors, cooperative managers, clean energy technicians and finance coordinators, with more than 60% of positions meant for women. On the 2030 plan that is one direct role for every ten farmers. The case for it is that the roles exist because verification needs people on the ground, and that is a job category which grows with climate finance, not with a donor’s project cycle.

Who pays for the proof?

Korkmaz’s argument is that public innovation agencies are moving from backing high risk work for societal benefit toward projects that look attractive to follow on investors, and that the world needs these institutions to do what private capital will not. We read that as a description of our problem. Measurement, reporting and verification (MRV) for a smallholder plot earns no exit. It earns trust, and trust is paid for by someone else’s grant, which is why we describe our work as research, product development and technical assistance, not as a start up chasing a sale. The risk is that the shared layer gets priced like a product while its benefits accrue to everyone who later lends to or buys from the cooperatives it verifies.

The newsletters also show how uneven funding scale is. Set the figures side by side and the distance between prizes, grants and infrastructure awards is plain.

Four sizes of money, one axis

US dollars on a log scale. Case prize and Zipline award from the NextBillion issues, Kilimora figures from the AgriKonnekt page. Different things, shown for scale only; the Kilimora 2030 figure is annual and a target

$1K$10K$100K$1M$10M$100M$1BTop case-writing prizeUS$5,000$5,000Kilimora finance, 2025US$1.2 million$1.2MKilimora 2030 target, a yearUS$50 million a year$50MZipline expansion awardUS$150 million$150M

The Zipline award is 30,000 times the top case writing prize and three times our own annual 2030 target. That is not an argument against drone logistics. It is a reminder that capital goes where a buyer can already see a deliverable. Smaller programmes in the same newsletters sit at the other end: the 2026 Ashden Awards offered up to £40,000 for work protecting and restoring nature or widening clean energy access, open to the UK and Global South, and Accelerate Africa sought founders at the earliest stages. The gap between those two ends is where verified cooperative data could matter, because it turns a promising plot into something a larger financier can underwrite.

Why projects fail, and why mixed funding helps

Two stories in the newsletters touch the energy track of our work, which covers clean cooking and distributed green energy. The first is the GPA and Innovation Norway report on humanitarian energy, launched in a webinar on 25 November 2025, which identifies 25 common reasons projects fail and proposes a model for learning and reflection across the sector. We have not read it, and the launch notice gives the count only. The method is what we would borrow: write the failure list before the project, not after.

The second is Soluz Honduras. Richenda Van Leeuwen, Richard Stuebi and Jesse Colman describe a diversified funding model that let a solar provider serve very remote areas and very poor customers. Our version is structural. The plan has five independent revenue streams, none above 45% of the total by 2030, and carbon credits phased in only as pricing stabilises. On the stated floor of US$9 million a year in carbon value against US$50 million of total finance, carbon is about 18% of the plan. That is a sound hedge against a volatile market, and it matches the Soluz lesson that no single source should be allowed to put the platform at risk.

What lenders learn from the people they lend to

Carla Grados Villamar of 60 Decibels and Lucas Conrado of Estímulo report findings from interviews with more than 400 Estímulo loan applicants, with lessons for lenders on improving business outcomes and on preparing those who did not borrow for later credit. Two parts of that translate directly. Listening to applicants who were refused is as informative as listening to those who were funded. And preparation is part of lending, which is the job of our advisory track in investor readiness, due diligence preparation and impact documentation. AgriKonnekt already holds a time stamped record for every verified plot in the ClimaWallet, and our principles say farmers own their data. What we do not yet publish is what members themselves say changed, and what stopped others from joining.

Our own numbers, read sceptically

Our pages state a pilot in 2024 of 1,500 farmers with an estimated 24,000 tonnes of annual carbon potential, and a 2030 plan of 50,000 farmers and 180,000 verified tonnes a year. Divide through and the two disagree.

Carbon per farmer, pilot against plan

Tonnes per farmer per year. Pilot: 24,000 t over 1,500 farmers. 2030 plan: 180,000 t over 50,000 farmers. Our arithmetic on figures published by Kilimora

Pilot, 1,500 farmers2030, 50,000 farmers16.0 t3.6 t per farmerdown 77.5% on the pilotneeds a stated basis

There may be good reasons. The pilot figure is a potential, the plan figure is verified tonnage, and a larger group will include smaller plots and later adopters. But funders will do this division, so we should do it first. The same exercise on the other targets gives a clearer picture of what the plan assumes.

IndicatorNow2030 planImplied by our arithmetic
Farmers1,500 (2026)50,00033 times, about 140% a year over four years
Verified carbon24,000 t potential180,000 t a year7.5 times; US$50 per tonne at the stated US$9M floor
FinanceUS$1.2M (2025)US$50M a year42 times, about 111% a year over five years, against a stated 120%
Direct jobsNot stated5,000One role for every ten farmers

The finance growth rate is the one that holds together: 111% a year compounded for five years gets from US$1.2 million to US$50 million, and the stated 120% sits just above it. The farmer and carbon lines are where the story needs a footnote.

Who is in the room, and who is exposed

The NextBillion issue reported that more than 1,600 fossil fuel lobbyists were granted access to COP30, more than any national delegation except the host, Brazil. We would not stretch that into a claim about outcomes. It does show how well resourced the other voices are, and why smallholder cooperatives need evidence that travels: a verified, time stamped record can sit in front of a funder when the farmer cannot. The World Bank Live notice for “Forests for the Future” is a reminder that these rooms are also online and open, though we know nothing of that session beyond its title and date.

The Hinrich Foundation digest gives the other half. Deborah Elms writes that governments are adjusting to the disruption of US trade policy through new arrangements and by building on existing ones such as the CPTPP, but slowly while the stakes rise. Jia Hui Tee and the Harvard Growth Lab show Malaysia’s exports concentrated in electronics and machinery and therefore exposed to US tariffs. Angela Tritto describes four ASEAN economies, Singapore, Malaysia, Vietnam and Thailand, as central to global chip exports, each in a different way. The lesson for East African cooperatives is concentration. Our plan names buyers in the EU, North America and Asia Pacific, to be reached once prices stabilise, and certification under ISCC Carbon Farming and BioCarbon Standard. A cooperative with one buyer, one standard and one product carries the Malaysian risk at a smaller scale. Our reading of Kenya’s avocado value chain found the same shape in miniature: only about a fifth of national output leaves as fresh exports.

How the stories map to our work

StoryWhat it saysWhere it meets Kilimora
Africa needs jobsWorking age population grows by more than 20 million a year; agri food is the best bet for jobsCooperative cascade, 5,000 roles by 2030, over 60% women
Public innovation agenciesDrift toward venture logic leaves public good work behindMRV as shared infrastructure, grant backed research track
Humanitarian energy25 common failure reasons, a model for shared learningEnergy track: clean cooking and distributed power, with emissions avoided measured
Soluz HondurasDiversified funding reaches the poorest customersFive revenue streams, none above 45% by 2030
Estímulo and 60 DecibelsApplicant interviews show lenders what to changeAdvisory track, ClimaWallet records, member listening
COP30 lobbyingWell resourced voices dominate the roomVerified records for cooperatives that cannot attend
Trade and tariffsConcentrated exports are exposed to policy shiftsBuyer and standard diversification; avocado value chain reading

The verdict, and what we would ask for

The money is not missing in the abstract. Large awards exist, climate funds exist, and development agencies are still writing cheques. What is thin is the layer that turns a smallholder’s practice into a record a funder can rely on, and that layer is a public good that venture style funding will not carry on its own. Our response should be to publish the numbers behind our claims, diversify what pays for them, and keep farmers the owners of the data. Three signals would change this view: a reconciled carbon per farmer basis, published evidence of what the 70% MRV cost reduction is measured against, and member survey results that show the livelihood gains the plan assumes.

  1. Reconcile the pilot’s 16 t per farmer with the plan’s 3.6 t and publish the basis for each.
  2. State the baseline behind the 70% MRV cost reduction and the method used to measure it.
  3. Report revenue by stream each year against the 45% cap.
  4. Run a listening survey of members, including those who did not join or left, modelled on the 60 Decibels approach.
  5. Read the GPA and Innovation Norway report and write a failure checklist for the energy track before the next pilot.
  6. Frame verification as shared infrastructure in grant proposals, and ask funders to pay for it as such.
  7. Report jobs as roles per ten farmers and women’s share, by role type, every season.
Sources & notes

SOURCES: Hinrich Foundation newsletter, 25 November 2025 (Deborah Elms; Angela Tritto; Jia Hui Tee and the Harvard Growth Lab; Dinny McMahon and David Zhang; roundtable with Tan Kiat How); NextBillion newsletters, November 2025 (Loïc De Cannière on agri food jobs; Emre Eren Korkmaz on public innovation agencies; GPA and Innovation Norway report launch; Soluz Honduras by Richenda Van Leeuwen, Richard Stuebi and Jesse Colman; 60 Decibels and Estímulo survey by Carla Grados Villamar and Lucas Conrado; Ashden Awards; Accelerate Africa; Zipline award; COP30 lobbyist report); World Bank Live event notice, “Forests for the Future”, 18 November 2025; Kilimora, Home, About Us and AgriKonnekt, as shown on 4 November 2026. These are newsletter summaries a year old, the underlying reports were not read, and Kilimora figures are as published by us and not independently verified. The cumulative working age figures, the 0.025% share, the 30,000 and three times ratios, carbon per farmer, implied growth rates, the 18% carbon share, US$50 per tonne and jobs per farmer are our own arithmetic.